The stink. Call. Tell them we know

Posted

When you are the next person into the bathroom, and you detect an unmistakable odor, it’s not much of a mental exercise to mark the smell’s origin. The person who is scurrying away from the scene might deny it, but we all know, right?

That’s not unlike the 10-month-long scatalogical flap between the city and one of its larger tenants, the co-op on Federal Street owned by Dairy Farmers of America [DFA]. 

Complaints about the smell coming from the creamery began last winter, shortly after the creamery responded to the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources’ order that it do a better job of treating its food waste products. The creamery had been fined $200,000 for dumping its raw food materials. It was forced to install a new reverse osmosis system which is akin to installing a mini-wastewater treatment plant in the middle of the city. 

That’s also when the smell began. It was an unintended consequence of the stepped-up treatment of its waste product. But the localized odor was unmistakable, and persistent. And everyone knew the culprit.

At a City Council meeting a month or so ago, DFA’s legal representative Peter Raymond stood up to oppose the city’s intent to seek a public health order and, potentially levy a daily  $10,000 civic complaint penalty. He said, “So I think with those and with that plan going forward, there isn’t a public health hazard. The company’s certainly committed to work aiong with the city.”

Except they aren’t.

At the last council meeting DFA officials flatly denied the company was the source of the smell. They brought engineering data that supposedly showed “no hydrosulfuric compounds” were being detected on or near the Federal Street plant.

So the people who have been calling in to city hall who live near the creamery, and who smell raw sewage are mistaken? 

So it’s purely coincidental that the offending smell was noticed at the same time the creamery began operating its little mini-wastewater treatment plant?

Of course, just like the person who was in the bathroom before you was not the offender. You’re just imagining things. Like the smell.

There was a time - and not long ago - that the coop was locally owned and operated. It was 2019 and called the St. Albans Cooperative Creamery. It had just entered its 100th year of operation. That was also the year that the creamery merged with DFA. 

DFA is headquartered in Kansas City, half the nation away. It began the process to upgrade the Federal Street plant and to produce a lot more product almost immediately. It was something the coop knew was necessary, but didn’t have the money to do so. Milk prices were low and the opportunity seemed to be beneficial to all parties.

But the difference between being owned and operated by DFA and owned and operated by the former board of local dairy farmers [and the coop members] is that the local board lived and worked here and would have smelled what was going on. They would have acted responsibly. Today, the fumes don’t quite make it to Kansas City. They may be the ones who just left the bathroom, but they aren’t about to admit it. They can’t smell it. Our problem, not theirs. 

So the city has decided to ask for the community’s support. If you smell something, call it in. The number is 802-309-1775. Or you could call the company’s headquarters in Kansas City at (816) 801-6455. Tell them it’s about the smell in St. Albans. Tell them you know they were the last ones to use the bathroom. Tell them to play nice. Tell them to be responsible, to do the right thing. Tell them that we understand the old saying about the smell of a dairy farmer’s fields being the “smell of money.” 

Tell them that’s NOT the smell coming from DFA’s operation on Federal Street.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here