The 'silent death' behind the Legislative curtain

Posted

In the halls of the Vermont Legislature, it’s called the “silent death.” It’s when both political parties outwardly agree on a legislative objective, but one party quietely works behind the curtains to make sure it doesn’t happen.

That’s happening now.

Last September, Gov. Phil Scott issued an executive order to address the state’s housing crisis. He said not enough was being done and he exercised his authority to, among other things, expedite the permitting process, ease energy code reforms, relax regulations governing wetland regulations, and produce an inventory that identified sites suitable for affordable housing.

Not unexpectedly, environmental groups and legislative leaders opposed the governor’s order, saying it was an “overreach” of executive power. They argued that the governor can’t roll back environmental regulations set by the Legislature. They made it clear that if the governor pushed forward with his executive order, he would be challenged in court.

[Oh, but they insist they are still committed to meeting the state’s housing needs.]

Rather than waste time in court [at taxpayer cost], Julie Moore, Secretary of the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources, and Kerrick Johnson, Commissioner of the Department of Public Service, initiated the rulemaking process to implement key components of the executive order.

At the same time, several legislators also drafted legislation that would support the implementation of the executive order. Sen. Thomas Chittenden and Sen. Pat Brennan sponsored S.266, and Rep. Michael Boutin worked on an amendment to S.632, a lengthy document in legislative parlance called a “technical corrections “ bill. Both pieces of legislation would accomplish two things: they would negate the argument that the governor was exceeding his authority, and they would provide a clear, defensible way to set the necessary rule-making in place. It would help clear the barriers that currently make it difficult and expensive to address the state’s 40,000-home deficit.

One would think that on an issue of this importance, the legislative process would allow the committees with the appropriate jurisdiction to vote on the bills’ merits. If they passed committee reviews, they would be sent to the floor for consideration.

But that doesn’t work for the legislative leadership. They couldn’t take the chance that the bills might pass. Thus, they have ensured these bills won’t get out of committee. They’ve been tabled. No votes.

This is the “silent death.” The bill dies, but few outside the legislative leadership know why.

Except we do.

Democrats are in a tough spot. The party’s base includes environmental groups like VNRC, CLF, and VPIRG, and they are opposed to S.632 and S.266, contending the bills weaken the state’s web of environmental laws. At the same time, the state’s number one issue is the lack of housing, which is caused by the state’s overwrought regulatory system. What the Democrats are doing is trying to finesse the legislative playing field so that they can have it both ways: they maintain the support of environmental groups [and their donations] by refusing to allow a vote on the bill, yet they publicly side with the vast majority of Vermonters who continue to pay the price for a lack of housing.

What Vermonters should ask is how it is that the legislative leadership can tell Vermonters that the state’s number one issue is the lack of housing, and then, in the same moment, refuse to allow a vote on legislation that would help make additional housing possible?

The legislative leadership has its priority, which is to protect its members from having to go on the record with an up-or-down vote on bills to reduce the cost of housing by streamlining environmental regulations, which could be problematic in next November’s election. By refusing to allow a vote, Democrats don’t have to worry about angering environmental groups and losing their support. At the same time, they will continue to assure their constituents [falsely] that they are doing everything they can to get those homes built.

As Ms. Moore has stated, it’s a “fundamental breakdown of government accountability,”

And it happens because it’s not brought to the public’s attention. No wonder people have little trust in the political will of our leaders to put the public’s needs above their own. No wonder the average Vermonters wonder why they can’t find housing.

The silence needs to end. It’s a classic example of why it’s important to speak truth to power.

By Emerson Lynn

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here