When we build homes in Vermont, we build them on large plots of land. In fact, no state in the nation has larger lot sizes. Not close. It’s the way it’s always been. When we try to build closer to one another, people complain. We have laws, after all. If those fail, we have zoning ordinances. It is who we are.
For the longest time this snobbery worked. Until it didn’t. Which was about a generation ago when the state’s population began to decline, the percentage of the elderly began to rise, and rural Vermont began to lose its farmers.
Since then, we’ve fiddled around the edges trying to figure out a way to grow, to build enough new homes, without ruffling the feathers of those who’d prefer to keep their neighbors at arm’s length. There has been no attempt to contemplate serious change because there is a serious portion of Vermont that opposes growth. They’d rather do without. After all, they have theirs.
Meanwhile, the housing shortage has grown exponentially. We’re 40,000 homes short of where we need to be. And that cannot be addressed one site-built house at a time. Particularly when that site-based house, even with government help, can run north of $350,000 to $450,00 to build.
We have neither the time nor the money to fill our needs.
Vermont is not the only state to suffer similar challenges. But other states are choosing different paths in the need to address their housing issues, and chief among them is figuring out how to use manufactured home parks as places to live for workers, for new homeowners, and for the elderly looking for essential amenities and to escape from rural loneliness. They are also increasingly being looked as an answer to climate vulnerability, community economic development and how land can be used more equitably. And, of course, there is the issue of cost - the average price of a manufactured home in 2023 was $128,300. A double-wide home for that amount comes with 2,000 square feet, 2-3 bedrooms and two baths. And it’s new.
The arguments against manufactured homes are largely stereotypical: They are disconnected, they are exploitative, and they are shoddy, and for the downtrodden.
These arguments no longer apply to manufactured homes and considering the age of Vermont’s housing stock, they are a step up from what a large percentage of Vermonters live in. There are additional benefits to manufactured homes:
• You can place 8 to 15 units per acre, which addresses our penchant for density.
• For every manufactured home placed, there is one home that is opened to the market. It’s the quickest way to make new housing available.
• Vermont is struggling to figure out how to push development from flood plains to higher ground and to do it affordably. Manufactured home parks would be the cheapest and best housing available [which is also affordable.]
• Vermont places a premium on keeping the land open. The Legislature passed the Community Resilience and Biodiversity Protection Act which sets the goal of keeping 50 percent of Vermont’s land area open by 2050. What better way to do that than to build sites for manufactured homes?
• There is an amped up effort to stress the need for minimizing the footprint of our housing, which has direct implications for our environment. Studies show that large homes generate about 25 percent more greenhouse gases than residences in lower income neighborhoods.
• If we were to build these manufactured home parks, and if we were to structure them so that the residents also owned the land they were on, then this would also be a way for the owners to build some equity, which, in turn is better for the state’s economy.
• One of Vermont’s biggest challenges is the social and economic isolation of its elderly, which is particularly rampant in our rural areas. These manufactured home parks could address that, which would also address other issues, like the difficulty of delivering healthcare, and other essential services, to the infirm.
There will be those opposed to such efforts. We would expect that. It’s change. It’s not what we’ve grown used to. But what we’ve grown used to no longer works and it’s essentially bankrupting us. Unless we’re able to build homes at a scale that makes homes affordable and plentiful, then we will continue our decline.
Instead of focusing on what we can’t do, let’s focus on what we can.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here