When the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] was established in 2011, it was assigned two key responsibilities: to improve the health of Vermonters and to control costs. To accomplish that meant “greater transparency and accountability” in the state’s healthcare system.
So how are we doing? Well, it’s been a ride. GMCB is made up of five individuals appointed for six-year terms, and some boards have been stronger than others. We said at the time of its creation that the five individuals would be among the most powerful people in Vermont. It was true then and remains so. Vermont’s health care system constitutes 20 percent of the state’s gross domestic product. It’s one of the few services that touches every Vermonter. And those five individuals essentially control much of what happens with our healthcare.
It also follows that the tougher the healthcare scene, the tougher the board’s job. Which is where we are now. Our hospitals are stressed, to put it mildly. Particularly the more rural ones. Most are losing money or operating on razor-thin margins. There is a push to consolidate services, but to do so in a way that doesn’t compromise the community's access to its hospital or essential services. But that’s a balancing act with no end in sight. What’s an essential service? What’s a fair price? How does the word “affordability” translate in today’s health care debate?
The difficulty of the debate, at least one part of it, is being played out between the Rutland Regional Medical Center’s decision to eliminate its inpatient pediatric unit and the GMCB’s decision to hold a public hearing questioning the hospital’s decision. The hospital is questioning whether the GMCB has the legal authority to overturn a hospital’s choice in how to budget its services, something that’s relatively unusual in the process.
According to GMCB chair Owen Foster, a new law passed last session gives the board the discretion it needs to tell hospitals how much they can spend, and how their budgets align with the goal of regionalized care. Nothing is beyond its review.
In other words, the board has the authority, in the Rutland case, to tell the hospital it forbade the cut and still force the hospital to live within the same budget. “That would mean that a hospital [including Rutland] may have to cut administrative staff, they may have to cut marketing, they may have to cut lobbying, they may have to come up with the money from somewhere else. They may have to eat into their reserves,” Mr. Foster said.
Should the GMCB force Rutland to maintain its pediatric unit, the hospital would have to find other places in its operation to find $3.1 million to make up the difference. That’s a lot of money.
Whether or not that happens will depend in part on the strength of Rutland’s case in the Dec. 5 public hearing.
It’s going to be a decision watched carefully by Vermont’s other hospitals, including Northwestern Medical Center in St. Albans. If the new law encourages the GMCB to guide each hospital’s mission, thus ultimately forging together a more regional approach to health care, that will necessitate a more robust communication effort than now exists. Communities need to know how their local health care options will be affected. The strength, or availability, of a good hospital is often the deciding factor in whether a family stays, leaves, or even entertains the thought of moving here from elsewhere.
That, in part, is why the GMCB is questioning the decision by Rutland’s hospital to shutter its pediatric unit. Once gone, it’s difficult to bring back.
It’s the responsible thing for the GMCB to consider. It also shows that the board is concerned not only with the need to control costs, but also with keeping intact the services that make the hospital vital to its patients.
Vermont has the highest health care premiums in the nation. Costs have to be controlled. But nothing good will ever come of Vermont’s push to reform its health care system if the services it offers are ravaged. In that respect, the GMCB’s decision to question Rutland’s decision is an important one.
We are at the very beginning of reworking Vermont’s health care system. The outcome will be measurably different than what we have now. Is this what our legislators envisioned 14 years ago when they signed into law Act 48, creating the regulatory board, the only one of its kind?
No.
But it’s good that the GMCB exists. We’re beyond the point where health care can be a hospital-by-hospital decision. But it’s also going to be a journey that requires a ramp-up in communication. The give and take between controlling costs and providing essential services will be every bit as difficult and controversial as what we are experiencing with the push to revamp Vermont’s educational system. And just as important.
It’s time to pay attention, for Vermonters to ask what’s in store for their health care options.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here