The issue in Vermont is growth

Posted

Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman Thursday announced he would run for reelection, quelling any speculation he would mount a second challenge to Gov. Phil Scott, or run for the Senate should Sen. Bernie Sanders announce his retirement this month.

In making the announcement he said: “This is a critical moment for our state. Vermont is becoming less affordable for working families. We face a housing crisis, a climate emergency, and rising regressive property taxes that are crushing working-class people. As Vermonters suffer, our healthcare system costs continue to rise at unsustainable rates. In the face of continued threats to our democracy, we must come together.”

Mr. Zuckerman’s statement echoed some of what former Gov. Howard Dean outlined in a letter he submitted explaining his contemplation of a race against Gov. Phil Scott. Mr. Dean said he was “deeply alarmed by the coming fiscal crisis in Vermont” and was also concerned about issues of affordability. Mr. Dean made a specific reference to healthcare, an issue he says has “fallen by the wayside.” He said the system needed change saying it “…will not be free and it will not be government-run but it will be universal, and I believe it is within our reach without breaking reasonable budgetary predictability.”

Vermonters could fairly ask what has changed in Vermont since former Gov. Peter Shumlin tried, and failed, to push the state to a single-payer healthcare system. Are we better off financially today than we were then? Mr. Dean says we can expect fiscal turmoil over the next few years and that the “numbers will be staggering.” 

Do we have the bandwidth to deal with the financial challenges of our health care system, a severe lack of housing, and a deeply-in-the-red educational system?

No, we don’t. That’s particularly so within our existing tax structure and Mr. Dean made note that he is “on the frugal side” when it comes to tax issues.

Which brings us to the unavoidable conclusion: We can’t tax our way out of any of these issues. There aren’t enough of us. Nor are there enough of us with sufficient wealth to do so. It’s not going to happen.

We have two options; the first is to cut expenses, which is anathema to legislators and the special interests knocking on their doors. The second is growth, which has been Mr. Scott’s focus but not Mr. Zuckerman’s or much of the Democratic Party. We are already a highly taxed state and have little headroom to be able to raise taxes enough to meet the state’s fiscal challenges. 

Growth is a long-term play, not something that can be put in place with any expectation of near-term returns, which is why it’s not addressed with any specificity by those running for office. It doesn’t have the appeal of something voters could imagine would help them immediately.

There is still comfort to be drawn from the collective focus of Gov. Scott, Mr. Dean, and Mr. Zuckerman. All of them recognize that things are seriously amiss in Vermont and contrary to Mr. Zuckerrman’s observation, these are not issues that apply only to “working-class people.” A troubled educational system affects us all. A lack of housing affects us all. Shortfalls in available employment pools affect us all. An expensive and understaffed healthcare system affects us all. 

If as Mr. Dean states, Vermont cannot pay for today’s programs by “borrowing from tomorrow’s Vermonters” then we need to figure out how to grow the pie, not how to slice it into smaller pieces.

That’s the conversation we should all hope for and insist upon.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here