When Gov. Phil Scott delivered his State of the State address last week he sounded a note of frustration along with his usual call to arms. It was his eighth legislative session as governor. Every session brings its own drama, but every session also carries with it the repetition of the past, core issues that remain looming, but unaddressed. It is easy to understand Mr. Scott’s frustration.
The session’s immediate drama could include how we are to recover from the summer’s flooding, or the need to rid ourselves of the scourge of flavored tobacco. But the core issues, the ones the governor keeps repeating, are public health, affordability, and housing. He illustrates them in this paragraph of his address:
“So let me share three numbers from your Joint Fiscal Office that tell you everything you need to know: 14,000, 28,000, and 48,000. As of 2022, we have 14,000 fewer kids under the age of 18 than we did in 2010. During that same period, we have 28,000 fewer adults ages 40 to 54, which is the core of our workforce. And we have 48,000 more over the age of 65. This is all within just 12 years, but this is nothing new. It’s been happening for decades.”
The governor has “shared” those numbers before. Repeatedly, in fact. He repeats them because they remain unaddressed and we will get nowhere until they are.
His frustration?
“Now, I’m a realist, and I know you have a super-majority. You’ve proven the final budget, and the growing burden of taxes, fees, and other policy-driven costs, is in your hands.
“So all I can do is make my case, which is the same case I’ve made to Vermonters since I first ran for governor…”
The Democrats are well aware of the governor’s continual focus on the state’s demographics, which, to address, would require an overhaul in how the state operates and how it is perceived. It would also require prioritizing a few needs to the detriment of the many the Legislature considers. Legislators have always preferred to do the opposite; politically it is more palatable to give all causes a little than to give them nothing shuffling their appropriations to more pressing causes.
Vermont’s demographics are undoubtedly the primary obstacle to our future prosperity. We can’t continue to see a decline in the number of our youth and our working-age population and, at the same time, see a substantial rise in the number of elderly without also experiencing a weakened economy.
How dire do things need to become before we act in unison to get where we need to be? That’s the question Vermonters are asking. That’s what frustrates the governor.
Although affordability is central to all discussions, it’s probably less about affordability than it is a clear plan about what needs to be done first and why.
Housing, for example, is clearly at the center of everyone’s agenda, the governor’s and the Legislature’s. Yet, we piddle around the edges of the issue. If it’s so crucial, then why is it so difficult to sacrifice resources in the near term for long-term gain?
A rising tide, it’s said, lifts all boats. But when the tide runs out we see what remains. We don’t have the resources to lift all boats. Not for long. We need to choose. The choices are difficult, but if they are not made then we will continue what the governor alluded to in his state-of-the-state address, which is the slow, but inevitable state of decline.
The change will come when we begin to see optimism in making the difficult choice. This session would not be soon enough.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here