The governor vs legislature on pay

Posted

It’s the pocketbook nerve we all find most sensitive, which is true for Vermont legislators as it is for the layperson. Legislators contend they are underpaid for the work they do and that current pay levels discourage working-class Vermonters from a job in the Statehouse. 

Legislators passed a bill last year that would double their pay over four years at a cost to taxpayers of $4.7 million. The governor vetoed the bill. He said it was hypocritical for legislators to boost their pay while passing on additional costs to taxpayers. The veto was sustained by a single vote, which was a surprise given the Democrats’ supermajority. The failure to override the veto showed how sensitive legislators are to lining their pockets. Self-aggrandizement can be an election losing issue.

Legislators have returned to Montpelier, and among the first bills introduced were bills to increase legislative pay. Clearly, legislators intend to push until successful. 

The lead on the issue is Sen. Ruth Hardy, D-Addison, and the bill introduced this session reflects the same pay levels as last year’s bill, but it eliminates health insurance benefits. The total cost drops from $4.7 million to between $2.5 and $3 million, a significant difference.

The legislation also ties the wage of a lawmaker to the average Vermont salary. It reduces the number of days pay a legislator can earn when the Legislature is not in session. The number was dropped from 34 days to 20. The paid days would not be automatic. Legislators would be required to request the time earned and would need to show that the work was related to the work of the Legislature.

Any reasonable assessment of the bill proposed this session versus last session would acknowledge the improvement. That said, the governor is still likely to veto the bill and the timing, in a political sense, leans in his favor. The state has less available money now than a year ago, and taxpayers face much higher costs. It’s also an election year.

Ms. Hardy’s bill is likely the one the Legislature will consider, but last Friday, Sen. Tanya Vyhovsky, P/D-Chittenden-Central, introduced her own bill, one aimed at creating more equity between the executive branch and the legislative branch. Her bill would cut the governor’s salary and those of his cabinet heads to what general assembly members are paid [other than the Speaker of the House and the President Pro Tempore of the Senate.

Ms. Vyhovsky’s bill is nothing more than revenge. Or unrestrained self-importance. She says it’s about the need to build equity between the branches of government, contending that the size of the paycheck is what makes things equal. It’s not, as her seat mate, Ms. Hardy, shows in her own bill. There are 180 members of the House and Senate. There is one governor. There is one person who heads each of the cabinet positions. Suggesting an individual legislator shoulders the same burden as those targeted by Ms. Vyhovsky is absurd.

Ms. Vyhovsky knows this and admits her bill doesn’t stand a chance. The question is why poison the air with legislation that makes compromise more difficult? Democrats failed to override the governor’s veto by a single vote last year. It would seem they need every vote they can get, why give the governor any advantage by being nasty? Isn’t this the sort of political division voters find objectionable?

Ms. Hardy has done the work required and made the necessary cuts. She has offered a bill that meets the needs of a 21st century legislator in Vermont. If it helps to improve the quality, and availability of those who want to be part of the legislative process in the statehouse, it’s an acceptable price to pay.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here