Here is what we weren’t expecting in Sunday’s Super Bowl game: Boxer Mike Tyson, the “baddest man on the planet,” urging Americans to eat real food, not the highly processed food that has made the nation “the most obese, fudgy people.”
The black and white ad was paid for by Make America Healthy Again and has Mr. Tyson saying, “The most important fight of my life isn’t in the ring. I’m not fighting for a belt; I’m fighting for our health. We have been lied to, and we need to eat real food again.”
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. views the ad as a call to action and the “most important ad in Super Bowl history.”
Because the ad has the support of Mr. Kennedy and the Trump administration, it automatically becomes highly politically charged, inviting Democrats to find fault, no matter the message.
A tamed-down version of the conflict is being played out in Vermont with the Scott Administration pursuing language that would ban SNAP [Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program - 3Squares VT] recipients from using their federal dollars to buy “non-nutritious items.” It’s a move supported by Vermont’s Department of Health, and opposed by food security advocates.
Vermont Treasurer Mike Piechiak, who has obvious designs on the governor’s office, called the proposed ban “costly and ineffective” and would “stigmatize families who rely on the program to put food on the table.”
Mr. Piechiak says, “In Vermont, we can be better than this and choose a different path- one that is true to our values, supports healthier communities, and treats our neighbors with the dignity they deserve.”
But what, exactly, would that different path look like? How do you push Americans to a healthier diet if you don’t change the consumers’ behavior? And, in the long run, what threatens a person’s dignity more - allowing the food industry to continue producing highly processed food that’s also addictive and unhealthy, or shifting the consumers’ choices so that they are eating food that is healthier?
The politics of the choice are obvious, and Mr. Piechiak has decided that there are more votes among those who don’t want their food choices limited than among those who do.
Maybe. Maybe not. Polls are beginning to reflect a public concerned about its food choices.
As the medical community has firmly established, you are what you eat, and roughly 60 percent of the American diet consists of ultra-processed foods. Remember, too, that the most recent data shows that approximately 75 percent of American adults are overweight or obese, and that 90 percent of the $4.9 trillion spent on health care goes to treating our chronic care needs, which is largely fueled by obesity. In fact, obesity is being called a “gateway” disease that is linked to over 200 chronic diseases and health-related conditions.
Where is the dignity - for anyone - in continuing such behavior? Can we really pretend that the majority of us are okay with our food choices?
How can we complain about the high cost of health care if we are not willing to challenge the food industry’s unrelenting push to sell us food that makes us the least healthy nation in the developed world? How do we ignore the challenge before us, knowing that the United States has the developed world’s highest rate of “avoidable” deaths and chronic conditions like diabetes and heart disease?
Vermont is one of roughly 30 states that have either made the move to ban unhealthy foods for SNAP recipients or are considering such a move; several, such as Iowa and Colorado, already have, and there is no political ideology driving these decisions. It will be a full year before Vermont gets there, and it’s a rule change that doesn’t require the Legislature’s approval. As has been noted by the administration, we’re in the listening stage. No final decision has been made.
As disreputable as Mr. Kennedy has been in his short tenure, this is the one thing he’s gotten right: The food industry and its ultra-processed products are bad for our health, and it’s come at an extraordinarily high cost in terms of our health and what we pay for our health care.
This battle isn’t about dignity, as Mr. Tyson says; it’s a fight about our health, and it’s no place for people to sit in the stands tossing peanuts at those trying to make a difference.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here