The cost of rising crime is an issue that must be faced locally

Posted

If there is a single common-denominator issue facing Vermont’s cities and towns it’s public safety. As the rate of crime rises and drug-related overdoses continue a skyward trajectory, the public is feeling at risk, even in conservative rural areas like Franklin County.

We find ourselves betwixt and between. There is a palpable urge to do what’s necessary to reduce the crime, including a more aggressive judicial system. Then, there is an equally strong urge to resist paying what’s required to get there. 

This is playing out in St. Albans City and Town, where town taxpayers will be asked to spend a million dollars more than in years past. The combined city-town police arrangement will be more professional and more robust, and the two municipalities are the county’s largest and, thus, have more crime-related issues than the rest of the county, but the public safety budget for both communities is significant.

This quandry is also playing out in Swanton Village and Swanton Town, and to a greater degree than in St. Albans. The two municipalities have combined efforts to figure out how to upgrade Swanton’s police department, including 24/7 coverage of Swanton Town’s population. The Village purchased property last spring next to its municipal center, the purpose being to add room for its operations, including doubling the size of its police department. The price tag is a whopping $19 million.

The price tag would affect town residents more than village residents. Town residents only pay for eight hours of protection daily, whereas village residents already pay for around the clock coverage. The village only has a third the population of the town, so it also makes sense that the town, with its much larger population, helps shoulder that increased cost.

Town Selectboard Chair Earl Fournier put it succinctly: “If the town wants the protection, this is what it’s going to cost.”

He’s correct. There may be other ways to bring the cost down a notch, like exploring relationships with other nearby municipalities, and figuring out ways to lessen the cost of the project itself, but the Village needs the space, and the two municipalities continue to add to their 8,000-plus residents. The need to expand services will only increase as the population grows.

In a Messenger story by Josh Ellerbrock, Village Manager Bill Sheets made the point that if the proposed expansion doesn’t happen - at one level or another - Swanton could end up having “no police in 5 to 10 years.” Mr. Sheets also made it clear that rural municipalities - like the Village - can no longer depend on outsourcing policing needs to outside groups - like the Vermont State Police or the Franklin County’s sheriffs department. 

“Building a police department on the back of contracts is broken,” he said. Police departments need the control to deal with issues of retention and recruiting, something outside contracts don’t allow.

The timing of Swanton’s $19 million proposal is a challenge given the squeeze on people’s pocketbooks dealing with this year’s inflation. There is also the expectation that school budgets will be high, as well. And Vermont has the distinction of already being a high-cost state. Asking for more rubs flinty Vermonters the wrong way.

We get that. But rather than claim what’s not possible, it’s crucial to push ahead figuring out what we can do. Mr. Sheets and Mr. Fournier are correct: Our public safety issues are not about to disappear. In fact, if they are not dealt with, they will only increase in numbers and severity. The only thing more expensive than doing what is necessary to provide communities the level of public safety they need, is to do nothing and expect things to improve on their own.

This pertains to the City and Town of St. Albans as it does Swanton Village and Town. And it starts with the little things. When Ace Hardware owner Gordon Winters spoke to the City Council last week about his continual problem with shoplifters who are now more “brazen” than ever, and who steal from local merchants with little fear of being caught or punished, that’s a warning sign to the community. The City of Burlington continues to struggle with its crime issues; Franklin County municipalities need to do what’s necessary to avoid the same fate.

Will it be expensive? Yes. But not as expensive as losing the security within our communities. In Swanton it may not be a $19 million building and a much larger police force, but it will need to be something. As Mr. Fourier says, “It’s not going to go away. No matter what happens in March, this is not going to go away. We’re going to have to deal with it.”

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here