The continual set backs of misinformation

Posted

 When the journal Nature published a climate study in April 2024, the world took notice. Understandably. The study showed that by 2049, climate change could wipe out the equivalent of the North American economy every year. That’s a $31 trillion loss. The study, researched by Germany’s Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, was considered a staggering indictment of the world’s lack of effort to recognize, let alone control, our meager efforts to deal with climate change.

One little problem. The study was riddled with errors. Last week, 20 months later, the Journal, which is a highly regarded publication, retracted the article, acknowledging the study’s “deep flaws.” For example, the research group had used its flawed numbers to predict a 62 percent decline in economic output by the year 2100. That, obviously, would be a humanitarian disaster.

[The number was reduced from 62 percent to 23 percent, which is still highly problematic.]

When the study was first released, the public reaction, particularly among environmentalists, was to use it to back their particular causes. Who could blame them? They were following the “science” of those with the reputations necessary to offer credible guidance.

The fear now, of course, is that critics will use Nature’s retraction to create doubt about other studies, policies, or laws. The issue is one in which we’re constantly trapped in the battle of extremes, an all-or-nothing approach taken by both sides.

We’ve had more than a touch of that in Vermont. Where would we be today, for example, if the state had done what was necessary to keep Vermont Yankee operating? Before the 2014 shutdown, the state had the nation’s lowest per capita emission levels. No longer. Today, we import more than 80 percent of our electricity from fossil fuel sources. Meanwhile, ironically, Microsoft is partnering with Constellation Energy to restart Unit 1 of the Three Mile Island nuclear reactor by 2027. 

Why?

They are pursuing sources of “clean, carbon-free” power. No emissions. 

Vermont lost its battle to the shrillness of the anti-nuclear opposition and misguided information about what the immediate future would demand.

When the Vermont Legislature pushed through the Global Warming Solutions Act of 2020, the Affordable Heat Act of 2023, and the proposed Clean Heat Standard, there was more than a little hyperbole fueling their passage. The mandates in the GWSA are not being met, and likely never will. The AHA is still being questioned by the PUC, as is the CHS. Both are considered unduly expensive. All three pieces of legislation are in place because the Democratically-controlled Legislature was able to override Gov. Phil Scott’s vetoes.

Where has all this led?

To the stalemate before us. 

Why?

Because we have yet to learn that moderation trumps excess. Because we have yet to accept that misinformation sets us back. Because we are more interested in the fight than we are the outcome.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here