The state is billing the town of Granville for more than $100,000 in delinquent property taxes over the last two years. If it’s happening in the small town of 300 in Addison County, it’s happening in Franklin County, and the rest of Vermont.
The story, written by Vermont Public, merits attention because it points to the limits of what Vermonters can afford to pay for their schools. Bruce Hyde, Granville’s town auditor, was quoted as saying that “every one of the people we have on our delinquent tax rolls is economically challenged, and they just can’t afford to pay their taxes.”
That’s a common refrain these days, for obvious reasons. The property tax has jumped over 40 percent in the last five years. Everyone’s noticed.
That’s a problem. It’s estimated that Vermont’s property taxpayers will face another seven percent increase this year, and that’s if the Legislature agrees with the governor’s plan to take $105 million from the general fund to buy down December’s estimate that property taxes would rise 12 percent.
If the folks in Granville can’t afford to pay their property taxes for the last two years, how are they going to manage another seven percent increase? They can’t. And, as property taxes increase, more people will become delinquent.
The way it works is that the municipality is on the hook to find the money, which means those who can afford their property taxes will be asked to make up the difference for those who can’t.
There isn’t any reason to think Granville’s situation isn’t happening in Franklin County.
There is also nothing in anyone’s playbook that can make next fiscal year’s increase go away. The proposal by the Senate Pro Tem Phil Baruth to cap budget increases would take effect in fiscal years 2028 and 2029. Progress on Act 73, intended to consolidate the state’s 119 school districts, is slow and may not happen at all.
Meanwhile, the state’s school districts are stressed, trying to figure out how to move forward. They are more than a little frustrated with Mr. Baruth’s idea [supported by the governor] of an arbitrary cap on spending. That begs the question of how school boards are to deal with the contracted salary agreements with their staff. It ignores the relentless increase in healthcare costs, which have totaled roughly 25 percent over the last two years and are expected to rise seven percent in next fiscal year’s budget.
If the Legislature were to slap on a two percent cap on their budgets, how would schools manage? They would have little choice but to cut in the only place they have control, which is in programming and maintenance. In other words, subjects taught, building maintenance/construction, or the number of staff. That’s a troubled path for a state that’s dealing with the ignominy of sinking test scores.
There is no way forward that avoids the pain. There is no way forward that brings relief to the people of Granville or delinquent taxpayers anywhere. But some suggestions could lessen the impact, and one came from Sue Ceglowski, executive director of the Vermont School Boards Association, who, according to the Vermont Public story, “offered lawmakers an alternative: cap the actuarial value of the teacher health benefits that now account for more than 12 percent of total education spending in some districts.”
The VTNEA opposes the proposal for obvious reasons. But is there a better, quicker, more obvious way to reduce costs and still focus on the undeniable need to raise our students’ test scores?
If there is, the people of Granville [and the rest of Vermont] would like to know.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here