The bill mainstream Vermonters aren't expecting

Posted

Vermont Digger positions the state’s gubernatorial race between Gov. Phil Scott and Amanda Janoo with this headline: “Vermont governor’s race will test voters’ appetite for raising new taxes or cutting them.”

If Vermont voters saw the race that starkly, Mr. Scott would win his sixth term with ease. Raising taxes has a dull ring to most Vermonters’ ears. Everything is more expensive than it’s been, and the objective is to bend the cost curve down, not up.

But the political calculus changes when voters are told the rich would pay their bills. That’s the story Ms. Janoo tells about universal health care. Ms. Janoo proposes raising over $300 million in taxes, which would give all Vermonters access to a primary care doctor. Free. She makes it clear that is step one. The objective is a healthcare system in which all services are free.

We’ve been there. Ask former Gov. Peter Shumlin. He pulled the plug on the “free healthcare” idea when the numbers showed it would be prohibitively expensive. It might be possible nationally, but Vermont can’t do it by its lonesome.

And that’s one of the problems with Ms. Janoo’s proposals. Vermont doesn’t have the wealth or the numbers to make her proposals work. According to 2023 numbers, there are only 1,047 tax filers in Vermont who have adjusted gross incomes above one million dollars. There are only 3,672 filers over $500,000 and 16,100 over $250,000. To make her $300 million figure work, she would need to slap a two percent surcharge on income over $250,000 and an eight percent surcharge on income above $1 million. And there are questions she has yet to answer, such as whether the proposal is indexed for inflation and whether couples could file separately. Regardless, the universal health care idea is only one proposal, and it would cost $300 million. What about housing? How do we catch up with the pension issues for our teachers and state workers? What about our schools and the six-billion-dollar backlog on school construction?

It becomes apparent very quickly that you have to dip deeply into our demographics to raise the sort of money Ms. Janoo needs to raise. We don’t have enough rich people to do it by themselves. Not even close.

We suspect Ms. Janoo knows this. She’s parroting Bernie Sanders and the party’s far left, and it’s working because the antipathy toward President Donald Trump is so profound that Vermonters are searching for any way they can to register their opposition. Mr. Trump is not on the ticket. Mr. Scott, a Republican, is. Mr. Scott, after a decade in office, is also facing voter fatigue, which makes it easier for voters to rationalize voting for someone else. Ask Mr. Shumlin.

Mr. Scott concedes that this may be his closest race, which is interesting because Ms. Janoo is far and away the most liberal of his challengers. And an unknown. Should she prevail and, as expected, the Democrats continue to control both the House and Senate, mainstream Vermonters could find the test for their “appetite” different from what they were expecting. And very expensive.

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here