When a Vermont employer writes a check to Blue Cross or MVP, the employee sees a premium deduction on their paycheck. But do you know where that $1,200 monthly premium check goes from there? Is it divided between the insurance companies and Vermont’s hospitals? Does it all stay in Vermont?
Most of us don’t have a clue where the money goes, except that, hopefully, it pays the doctor’s bill. Beyond that, it’s a mystery for most of us. What we know is that Vermont’s health care premiums are the nation’s highest and that the state’s regulator - the Green Mountain Care Board - is pushing hospitals to cut their spending. The process is working. The last two years have seen sizable decreases in insurance premiums.
But as the layers of Vermont’s health care onion are peeled back, we’re learning more, and it’s unsettling. The big concern came last week from GMCB chairman Owen Foster, who filed a dissenting opinion to the board’s decision on MVP’s 2027 rate proposal. He agreed with his colleagues’ proposed rate cut to Vermont’s hospitals. But he said the board had done half its work. He said they had dealt with the hospitals in Vermont. He said they had made no effort to address the health care providers who are not under the board’s control, including Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center and the Albany Medical Center.
What? Really? But they aren’t in Vermont. How can the GMCB affect what hospitals outside Vermont charge?
Easy. And that’s Mr. Foster’s point. The insurers in question - Blue Cross and MVP - are doing business in Vermont. They have the ability, and the responsibility, in Mr. Foster’s opinion, to apply the same pressures to health care providers outside Vermont’s system as they do to providers inside the system. He says it’s the board’s responsibility to force the insurers to do so.
That becomes more compelling when you understand that 44 percent of all medical-benefit costs fall outside Vermont’s 14 GMCB-regulated hospitals and therefore outside the Board’s direct hospital-budget authority.
44 percent. Wow. So the board is squeezing the 56 percent they control [our hospitals] and neglecting the other 44 percent, which get to do business as usual. And, guess what? Vermonters are paying the total cost, not just 56 percent of the tab. So, as Mr. Foster argues, we’re exporting a lot of healthcare premium money outside Vermont’s borders. As he wrote, this practice is “irrational.” The board has the authority to force out-of-state providers to adhere to the same restrictions and rates as Vermont’s providers. If we don’t, how do we manage if the 44 percent grows faster than today’s 56 percent?
You don’t. We have to apply the same affordability standard to the entire dollar, not just the part that’s easiest for the GMCB to reach. When Blue Cross and MVP make their budget cases before the GMCB, they should be able to answer basic questions: how much are they paying Dartmouth, Albany, and other out-of-state systems? What percentage of Medicare are these providers paying?
Dealing with those providers who do business outside Vermont is also the fair thing to do. If Vermont’s hospitals are being forced to cut their prices only to have the savings swallowed by faster spending by the out-of-state providers, then we should know that before the board considers another premium increase. If we fail to do this - as Mr. Foster makes clear - then we haven’t solved the affordability crisis; we’ve moved it. And when the numbers catch up with us, in a short year or two, then solving the problem becomes doubly difficult.
Mr. Foster concludes his dissent saying, “I cannot approve proposed rates that unnecessarily take some of Vermont’s limited health care dollars away from our providers to support well-financed and adequately compensated hospitals in other states.”
That’s not tough to understand. He has a long line of Vermonters who feel the same.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here