That 22.8% hike in health care premiums is only the beginning

Posted

When the Green Mountain Care Board agreed this week to allow BlueCrossBlueShield to raise its healthcare premiums on individuals by 19.8 percent and 22.8 percent on small businesses a strange thing happened: Nothing.

This is the third consecutive year that the GMCB has allowed insurers to raise their premiums by double-digits, but in the past the complaints were vocal and widespread. This year the response has been almost complete silence, most notably from the state’s executive and legislative leadership.

The reason for the premium increases is that the state’s regulator saw no choice. GMCB chair Owen Foster said, “While these rates are plainly unacceptable, the alternative of an insolvent insurer unable to pay for patient care was worse.”

Mr. Foster also said: “These rates reflect deep fundamental failures in our healthcare system and the immediate need for systemic change. Vermont must address its underlying healthcare cost structure, demographic and housing challenges, and transform its healthcare system if we are to alleviate the healthcare affordability crisis we are facing.”

He is correct, but the GMCB doesn’t have the authority to drive policy changes. It controls the budgets of insurers and our hospitals, but both are on life support, thanks, in large part, to outside forces. The situation has become so dire, and so inclusive, that there is no obvious villain. The whole system is so broken that fixing it will require starting over and no one is quite sure how that can be done.

Healthcare in Vermont is big business, making up 20 percent of the state’s gross domestic product. But the health of our insurers and hospitals is only part of the story. A 20 percent increase in health care premiums affects us all. We complained this year about a 13.8 percent increase in our property taxes, but a significant amount of our school budget expenses were tied to health care premiums. Think how that 22.8 percent increase will affect next year’s school budget expenses. That 22.8 percent also affects many small businesses in Vermont. How do they handle that level increase? That increase also affects a sizable percentage of the state’s nonprofits, organizations whose administrative expenses are capped at 10 percent. A 22.8 percent hike in healthcare premiums would put many of them over that limit. What happens to the grants that fund these nonprofits?

In sum, it’s not a pretty picture Vermont offers others to see. 

So why the silence?

And isn’t it odd that we have an assembled group of Vermonters [appointed by the Legislature] set to begin their assigned work to design a different educational system while a key part of the problem - healthcare costs - goes untended?

If our healthcare system is in a state of crisis, as Mr. Foster says, and if that crisis touches almost every other part of the state, why hasn’t there been an effort to attach the same importance to healthcare as was attached to school budgets?

This is not a one-day story. The longer it is ignored the deeper the problem becomes. But, the first task in solving any problem that involves lots of Vermonters is making sure they know the problem exists. 

That should not be difficult. But it would be reaffirming if we could hear the state’s leadership acknowledge the problem and suggest helpful ways forward. What we don’t need is more of what we have, which is silence from those who lead us.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here