When Gov. Phil Scott was asked about the House Ways and Means Committee’s move to raise income tax rates for the top one percent of Vermont’s taxpayers, his response was predictable: Not going to happen. He would veto any such bill. End of story.
The Democrats no longer have the numbers to override his veto. So why bother?
It’s an election year, and the backers of the proposed bill think the voters are on their side. It’s to their advantage, they think.
The bill is still being written, but the current draft would tax the top one percent of income earners. The state income tax for those affected is 8.75 percent. The bill would raise that to 12.7 percent, second only to California. [Nice company if you can afford it.] It would generate roughly $100 million. The bill would also generate another $48 million by assessing a 4 percent tax on net income from rent, dividends, capital gains, royalties, and passive income. The four percent proposal would cast a wider net, applying to households with a federal adjusted gross income of $250,000 for joint filers and $200,00 for single filers.
Supporters of the wealth tax are pushing forward for one overriding reason: It’s an issue of fairness; no one has any sympathy for those who have annual incomes of half a million dollars-plus. They are the one percenters. That should mean that 98 percent of us don’t have a dog in this fight. Fine. Tax them, raise the money for the rest of us. It’s a no-brainer.
What trips the Dems is creating the belief that taxing the wealthy solves the majority of our needs. It doesn’t. Vermont doesn’t have enough of them to make an overwhelming difference. And it doesn’t play well to push a wealth tax just to fill the state’s general fund. What’s the purpose? Why should Vermonters get excited about continuing our spending patterns without a specific goal? They shouldn’t.
The last time the Legislature passed a big tax was in 2023 with Act 76, the Child Care bill. It established a payroll tax of 44 percent of taxable wages, with employers responsible for three-quarters of the total and employees potentially responsible for 11 percent. Mr. Scott vetoed the bill, but his veto was overridden. The reason the bill had such strong support, even among businesses, is that the specific need was identified. Vermonters knew where the roughly $100 million was going. It was also pushed as a way to help employers fill their ranks. It was good business and wasn’t something intended to continue state spending in an indiscriminate, quotidian fashion.
If the Democrats want to benefit from the proposed wealth tax, they will need to say how it will be used and for what purpose. [Not an easy task.] If they continue as is, letting Vermonters believe the wealth tax is just an easy means by which a tiny percentage of Vermonters can pay for programs the rest of us use, then, as in the past, they will lose. They will open the field for Mr. Scott to do what he has always done, which is to cement the Democrats in the eyes of Vermonters as big spenders, small thinkers, and non-plussed by the shrinking personal budgets of Vermonters.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here