In an interview before this year’s Town Meeting Day vote, Messenger reporter Josh Ellerbrock asked David Winchester why he was interested in running for the village board presidency. Mr. Winchester said the people of Swanton “are grumbling for a different change and different perspective.”
Little did the people of Swanton know just how different Mr. Winchester’s perspective would be.
In a recent Facebook post, Mr. Winchester told the people of Swanton exactly what he had inherited as village president. A pretty picture it was not. He wrote: “…the thriving downtown days are long gone. Retail is very much gone mostly compared to the glory years. Most buy what they need at Costco or the internet. As far as entertainment value St. Albans is the only place. We will never be able to compete with that either. The only business I need on a regular basis that operates there is The Parts Store. Everything else no longer exists.”
So, the last person leaving Swanton needs to shut off the lights, right?
As one might expect, the reaction to Mr. Winchester’s backward-looking gloom was immediate and clear: what purpose is served by remembering what was and not what could be?
Recognizing he had erred Mr. Winchester tried to “clarify” his negativity with an additional post, which landed with an inglorious thud. He also tried to separate his “personal thoughts” from those of the village trustees, most of whom strongly disagree with Mr. Winchester.
But here’s the thing: the personal cannot be separated from the professional for an elected official. As village president, Mr. Winchester’s job is to be the village’s defender and to champion its needs. Period. He can’t do the job to which he was elected while publicly saying the village’s “glory years” are long gone. That should not be so difficult for Mr. Winchester to understand.
It’s also worth noting that Mr. Winchester referenced St. Albans as a place that had advantages Swanton does not. But it was not that long ago that St. Albans was battling its own demons. Retail traffic had dried up. The cracked sidewalks were sprouting weeds, not hope. There was little to do and the talk was about decline, about how good things used to be.
Like Mr. Winchester’s first post.
Today, St. Albans is the shiny place on the hill because the city’s elected leaders saw a different future and worked to get there. St. Albans did not return to its “glory years” but followed a different vision. It adapted to a changed environment.
But that changed environment also depended on people who saw opportunity, and who invested their own money and time to make it work. That effort will need to be revisited if the city’s vitality is to remain. Change is essential if growth is to be a constant. A decade or two from now St. Albans will have a new look; some of that is being put into place now. That’s the essence of forward-looking leadership.
That same spade work is beginning to take seed in Swanton. It was four years ago that Gordon and Debbie Winters opened Memorial Hardware in the middle of downtown Swanton. At the time, the property was vacant. Today, the store attracts over 60,000 shoppers, a 30 percent, year-over-year increase since its inception. It’s also added $1.35 million to the village’s grand list. A 70-seat restaurant is about to open, as well as a locally-owned bakery. There is the relatively new Bees on Broadway. Why are these new businesses in Swanton? In part, because Memorial Hardware is drawing a lot of foot traffic into the village of Swanton. Mr. Winchester should be lauding their efforts and their personal sacrifices.
Will Swanton ever be what it was a generation ago? Of course not. Nor should it strive to be. But instead of following Mr. Winchester’s sad lament about times past, it’s crucial Swanton follows St. Albans’ example and looks for its own interpretation of what the future holds and how Swanton might take advantage of it.
We’ve long acknowledged Swanton’s trump card, which is being at the center of the county’s outdoor recreation opportunities, i.e., Lake Champlain, the Missisquoi Refuge, the Missisquoi and Lamoille Valley Rail trails, and its proximity to the Canadian border. Swanton has advantages most rural towns in Vermont do not have.
But these opportunities will be squandered if the right leadership is not in place. Imagine what St. Albans would be today had it continued down yesterday’s road. The village trustees should waste no time in correcting Mr. Winchester’s assessment of Swanton’s path ahead. The focus must switch from what Swanton can’t do to what it can.
This is not a challenge to Swanton by its lonesome. It’s the central challenge that faces Vermont as it continues to age and our rural towns continue to decline in numbers.
Mr. Winchester misread the people of Swanton if he thinks they want him to spend his time running down the people who are working their hardest to make Swanton a more vital place to live and discouraging those who might want to move to a forward-looking community.
He needs to correct that.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here