Survival of VTSU depends on others backing Smith's proposals

Posted

In April, the Vermont State Colleges Board of Trustees picked Mike Smith as the interim president of the newly created Vermont State University for one reason: To avoid having to shut the place down or, at the very least, to stop the financial hemorrhaging and the troubling decline in VSU’s enrollment.

Mr. Smith said he would have a plan on the trustees’ desks in six months. He was true to his word. He actually gave them more than they might have expected. 

In early October, Mr. Smith’s first proposal - Optimization 2.0 - recommended the discontinuation of 10 VTSU programs, and the consolidation of 13 others. Eleven programs had their locations switched to be more efficient. [The proposal would have a minimal effect on students, since there are so few students in the targeted programs.]

The savings in Mr. Smith’s proposal would be an estimated $2.1-$3.35 million, which would come from the reduction of 20-33 of the current 207-member faculty staff.

The faculty union responded in a predictable manner. They opposed the cuts. They called the data behind the proposed cuts flawed. They said cutting the courses would drive student enrollment down. And, most predictably, they called on Mr. Smith to focus on the Vermont State College system’s administration which, they said, was bloated.

The union has made this same call for years. Why cut classes and teachers if those classes and teacher positions could be paid for by spending less on administrators in the central office?

Mr. Smith, to his credit, agreed with the union and said he would look into it. Last week, the other shoe fell. Mr. Smith said the VTSU administrative staff was “approximately 20% overstaffed.” He has proposed the elimination of 33 positions. He said the proposed cuts would save roughly $3.1 million annually. [Even more could be saved if the chancellor’s office were combined with the president of VTSU’s position. The union is correct. There is no need to have both.]

As expected, those identified by Mr. Smith as part of the “overstaffing” were none too pleased.

But Mr. Smith’s job, as shaped by the Legislature, was to find roughly $5 million in savings to pare down the university’s $22 million operating deficit. The Legislature made it clear the taxpayers could no longer afford to keep increasing appropriations for the Vermont State College system. Mr. Smith was to find the savings in a way that had the least deleterious effect on the schools and the students attending.

But here’s the thing: Mr. Smith’s proposals mean little if they fall on deaf ears. A new interim president, David Bergh, takes over from Mr. Smith this week. Does he follow Mr. Smith’s proposals? We need to know.

The VSC board of trustees says it wants both sides to know they are valued and that the choices before the trustees are difficult. But will a majority of the trustees support Mr. Smith’s proposals? Will they be vocal in their support?

The Legislature made it clear they want the $5 million in annual savings, but will the leaders of the Senate and House back Mr. Smith, or will they remain silent and be swayed by those who will urge them to just give them more money, with no, or far fewer cuts?

The governor is also keenly aware that if the cuts are not made the VSC system will continue its decline, but will the governor, in an election year, defend the cuts?

There is not a lot of time to play politics with the issue. If Mr. Smith’s proposals are not dealt with by the trustees, the Legislature and the governor in a timely manner, then the next wave of potential VTSU students will be staring a much weaker institution and, like the year past, enrollment could drop another 15 percent, or more.

What tomorrow’s VTSU students want in a school is stability, knowing the doors will still be open when they graduate. What they want is unity, to know that the parties in play agree with the school’s new direction and will cooperate to make it so. What they don’t want, and will not accept, is a continuation of the zero-sum battle that has been waged for the last several years, the internecine warfare that focuses on everyone’s concerns except the students’.

If that stability means eliminating a few courses, and offering buyouts to a small number of teachers and administrators, then that should be seen as an acceptable price to pay for a newly created university that educates thousands of Vermonters each year.

So, those in a position to add strength to Mr. Smith’s proposals should do so. It’s not a time to sit and watch, hoping others will step up. Mr. Smith has done the job he was asked to do. It is time for others to build up what  a state’s changing demographics and current political theater threaten.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here