Substance use program flawed, let's fix it

Posted

When you pay good money to fix something, or, to at least make it better, you stop when it’s clear it’s not working. The more pronounced the need, and the more money you spend, the speedier the decision to bail if failure is staring you in the face.

That is human nature 101. 

Government, as we know, is a different beast.  

For years we have struggled to deal with substance use disorders. Vermont has long been one of the states most bedeviled by addiction and the various troubles that spring from substance abuse. Yet, our progress is painfully slow, which has created more systemic issues, including homelessness and crime.

A group of non-profits and officials from Vermont’s judiciary are trying to address this issue by pointing out that Vermont’s “treatment” system is missing a key element in how it treats substance abuse patients. In a letter to Gov. Phil Scott, they said Vermont lacks “step-down” facilities that allow patients the time and place to fully transition back to a place where they are less susceptible to relapse.

Mark Redmond, executive director of the Spectrum Youth & Family Services in Burlington and St. Albans, was quoted as saying: “We have homeless kids who suffer from addiction. We send them to [rehab facility] Valley Vista. They’re back a couple of weeks later. It’s just wash, rinse, repeat, wash, rinse repeat.”

Other states provide longer treatment and recovery programs, and they use Medicaid to pay for the programs necessary to provide adequate time between rehab and living independently. Advocates - including those from the judiciary - are urging the governor to fund these step-down facilities or to change Vermont’s Medicaid system so that it can be used to achieve the objective, which is to offer longer-term programming than what’s being offered presently. The objective is to save lives and to slow the “wash, rinse, repeat” cycle to which Mr. Redmond alludes.

Obviously, a pen needs to be put to the proposal to know the cost and identify the revenue necessary to put the longer-term treatment options in place. But clearly what we have now doesn’t work and the churn of repeat patients through the system is costly, if not an outright waste of money. It also has a high cost from the perspective of the individuals, their families, and their communities. Lives have been lost, families have been hurt, and communities continue to suffer.

This should be an issue without a political bent. It’s to no one’s benefit to have a system whose mission cannot be completed because it’s improperly designed. It’s to no one’s benefit, to watch as patients go in and out of rehab without the same chance of success patients have in other states. It’s to no one’s benefit to live in a city that struggles with an increase in crime, just because the treatment for substance abuse patients is deficient.

The hope is that the governor follows the advocates’ lead and figures out how to round out the substance abuse treatment program in a way where patients have the best chance to succeed. That’s not “charity” spending, that’s an investment in the health of Vermonters and the communities they live in. What’s expensive, in all senses of the word, is to continue doing something that doesn’t work.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here