State should follow St. Albans, Killington on housing

Posted

Middlebury has attracted considerable attention for its plans to build a 250-home “neighborhood”, one of the largest housing developments in Vermont outside Chittenden County. The attention is deserved. When completed it could house roughly 500 people, more than the population of Isle La Motte, or the village of Cambridge, or roughly 40 of Vermont’s 277 municipalities. 

In 2023 South Burlington attracted similar attention with its 550-bed Catamount Run development to house the University of Vermont’s graduate students, faculty, and staff.

Both developments show what Vermont needs to do to address its housing shortage. The Middlebury project is described as an “ambitious, all-electric, innovative neighborhood on the scale and of a type that rural Vermont hasn’t seen in decades.” The South Burlington development is heralded as a way to be more accommodating to UVM’s needs.

Both are fabulous stories. May Middlebury’s tribe increase. So, too, with what’s happening in South Burlington.

Unfortunately, neither are models the rest of Vermont can follow. The Middlebury project would not exist if Middlebury College did not sit in the middle of Middlebury. The well-heeled college paid for the land and added $2.5 million to make the financing work. The South Burlington project would not exist if it were not for the University of Vermont’s willingness, and ability, to be the key financial partner.

And for the rest of us? Well, the majority of Vermont’s municipalities don’t have access to deep-pocketed colleges, or businesses with the wherewithal, or interest, in meeting the state’s need to add roughly 7,000 homes to its inventory each year for the next half dozen years.

We’ve been told repeatedly that we “can’t afford not to” when it comes to meeting our housing needs. The state’s health, so to speak, depends on more homes being built.

So, what to do?

There are two active examples of the best way forward. One is the City of St. Albans. The other is the town of Killington.

In St. Albans, we will have built 366 housing units by the end of next year. It’s been a decade-long project that has been made possible through our Tax Increment Financing District [TIF]. Together, that’s more housing units than Middlebury’s building, and all are within the city’s limits, adding to the strength of the city’s revitalized downtown [also part of the TIF program.]

How did it work? Very simply, the TIF program succeeded by helping the city put in the infrastructure so that developers could afford to take the other projects to completion. This is the public/private partnership that made the city’s TIF program the storybook example of how an “at risk” city’s downtown could be remade into something better than it was before. The city has added almost $100 million to the value of its grand list.

Killington is following the same path. Two years ago the town’s voters approved a $47 million bond to build the infrastructure [a municipal water line and new roads] which will enable developers to build new homes, and commercial and retail space at the base of the Killington ski resort. It’s estimated the TIF project will increase Killington’s grand list by $275 million.

As with St. Albans, Killington’s purpose was to put the infrastructure in place so developers could afford to invest in the rest of the extensive project. Both projects will pay for themselves many times over.

There is no reason this can’t be replicated elsewhere in Vermont. Unfortunately, there is a tendency in Vermont to push for ways to help the developers instead of pushing to get the infrastructure put in place first. That is upside-down thinking. It doesn’t work to help developers first thinking the infrastructure needs will take care of themselves. Once the infrastructure is put in place - roads, sewer and water, etc., - then developers can do the rest, as we’ve seen in St. Albans and Killington. It may look like it’s cheaper to incentivize the developer, since roads and water and sewer lines are expensive, but that’s penny wise and pound foolish. It does not work on a scale large enough to make a difference.

Gov. Phil Scott wants to expand the TIF program but little has been done to provide the necessary details. The Legislature is fully aware of the dire need to add housing but hasn’t provided much beyond lip service when it comes to making concrete proposals. There is also an element in Vermont that is skeptical of a TIF’s value. Vermont’s Auditor Doug Hoffer has long made the “but for” argument that development in our communities will happen regardless, that a municipality doesn’t need to spend a taxpayer’s dime to pay for something a developer would pay for anyway.

A stake has been driven through the heart of that argument. Those who wait, lose, as a sizable percentage of our communities can attest.

The TIF model used by St. Albans and Killington works. For those communities who do not have a Middlebury College or a University of Vermont, this is their only path forward. If Vermont’s housing shortage is the existential crisis it’s said to be then we need to start taking this argument, and our examples, to the governor and the Legislature.

Why are we waiting?

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here