In last week’s Messenger, former Burlington Mayor Miro Weinberger penned an op-ed about how Vermonters are better able and more inclined to say no to things than to say yes. Mr. Weinberger makes specific reference to the book “Abundance”, by Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson in which they contend that “Laws meant to ensure that government considers the consequences of its actions have made it too difficult to act consequentially.”
As Mr. Weinberger noted: They nailed us. That’s Vermont to a T. We can knock a barn down, but we can think of a thousand reasons not to build it back up.
“This conversation is 100% about us,” Mr. Weinberger wrote. “…he [Mr. Klein] could be talking about Vermont’s housing shortage. Because we’ve created a system that makes it incredibly hard to build the homes we need. Our state faces a critical housing shortage, yet the pathways to create more homes are gauntlets of redundant state and local rules, costly government mandates, and a permit appeals system that enables obstructionists.”
Okaaaay. Don’t sugar-coat it, Mr. Weinberger.
But he’s right. We apply that “politics of blocking” to much of what needs to happen in Vermont. The reform of our educational system. Figuring out how to contend with our health care crisis. Clean energy. Basic issues of affordability, including how to build the 41,000 housing units Vermont needs to build by 2030, or 8,200 a year. [In 2023, Vermont issued permits for 2,456 homes.]
Mr. Weinberger has made the state’s housing crisis his calling and serves as the executive chair of the advocacy group Let’s Build Homes. Politically driven or not [and what isn’t political these days?] it’s worthwhile to take the cause to all corners of the state. If we can’t even come close to meeting our housing needs, then how do we expect to grow? How do we expect to meet the needs of our labor force? How do we expect to maintain essential services? Why pretend that the secret is to lure people here, when the homes don’t exist, or they are too expensive?
The housing conundrum has become more problematic with the Trump administration’s tariffs. The cost of building homes just got more expensive and for how long is anyone’s guess. The uncertainty of the economy doesn’t help.
We have to look for any and all openings and Mr. Weinberger’s reference to “Abundance” and his recognition that Vermont’s lawmakers are better at putting up roadblocks than clearing the path is crucial for Vermonters to hear. We need to ask ourselves the question: if things aren’t working, how have we made things more difficult to resolve and what can we do to reverse course?
Here are two examples of ideas that are controversial, yet require exploring. First is the idea the Trump administration is pushing to sell or lease land owned by the federal government to help deal with housing affordability. That can be either the worst idea ever, or it can have some merit, it just depends on the details. In Vermont we have a little less than 10 percent of our land owned by the federal government, the largest of which is the 400,000 acres of the Green Mountain National Forest, which runs up the state’s spine, going from Bennington County to just below Vergennes.
If done correctly, finding a balance between preservationists and expansionists, the GMNP could be part of Vermont’s affordable housing mix. Several things would have to happen. First, the federal government would need to lease the land, at a basement bottom level, rather than sell it to developers. That way the land would not be subject to local or state zoning laws… i.e., Act 250. It would also reduce the cost of housing, making construction of the homes actually affordable.
Although most of the federal land being considered is in the West, there is no reason the federal government would not be open to leasing tiny bits of its land for affordable housing purposes in Vermont.
But, first, we’d have to say we’d like to explore the idea.
It’s understood from the outset that the opposition to such an idea would be instant. The optics are awful. Dealing with the Trump administration? Building homes on national forest land? But, to paraphrase Mr. Klein and Mr. Thompson, have we lost our vision as to what needs to happen to build things that matter? Why not review the land in a way that shows whether the building of homes makes sense, then decide?
The second idea also involves reexamining the amount of land conserved in Vermont over and above what the federal government owns. The Vermont Land Trust, for example, has conserved over 640,000 acres. The Vermont Housing and Conservation Board [VHCB], an independent state agency, has conserved 438,400 acres.
That’s a lot of land conserved.
Part of the VHCB conservation effort came about in 1989 when the Legislature implemented a program to allow the state to buy the development rights on farmland to prevent housing development. The purpose was two-fold. First, was to prevent housing development, second was to give farmers some needed cash and to keep the land in ag production.
We urged caution at the time. Some of the purchases were made on land near our municipalities, thus making housing development difficult, which is now evident. It also made little sense for farmers to lose their collateral in a one-time payout. Today, much of that land lies unused.
The question is whether there is a way to undo past conservation agreements without the preservationists thinking someone’s coming after their firstborn. In many respects, this is Mr. Miro’s point: We should be able to have that discussion in a manner that shows that the land could be used to produce the “abundance” to which Mr. Klein’s and Mr. Thompson’s book refers. That “abundance” would embrace the liberal need to build places for people to live and work.
In a perfect world that review would come from both conservation groups.
These are ideas that, perhaps, turn the tide of thinking away from the “politics of blocking” to the politics of building.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here