It’s less than eight weeks until the general election, and Vermonters are being pummeled by polls that say we might as well shut the doors. Over 60 percent of us report that our paychecks don’t keep pace with local costs, that 86 percent of us find Vermont fundamentally unaffordable, and that 60 percent of our young adults plan to live elsewhere.
Who has an answer for all that misery?
We’re not alone. National polls report the same misgivings about how hard it is to keep up with the cost of living. We still have 60 percent of Americans who can’t scratch together $2,000 for an emergency.
But back to Vermont. We’ve been screaming about an unsustainable cost curve for more than a decade, to no avail. In May 2024, the Legislature passed the yield bill that sets the educational property tax. It projected an almost 14 percent increase. In that year’s general election, the voters rebelled, and the Democrats lost their supermajority and their credibility.
Two years later, and we’re still trying to slay the same dragon. As we cut one head, two others appear. We’re not facing a 14 percent increase in property taxes, but the tax is still going up by almost four percent. Green Mountain Power just received permission to raise its rates by 5.5 percent, and our health care premiums are still inching upwards.
From the Legislature’s perspective, [they are the ones responsible for the state’s budget], we’ve gone from spending $5.8 billion to $9.4 billion in a short six years. That’s a 62 percent increase. When the Legislature is in the moment, doing its work and responding to special interests that ask for just a little more each year, we don’t pay much attention. It’s the Legislature. It’s what they do. But over six years, the increase is stunning. People are waking up to bills they can’t afford.
Here’s one big example: Today we are educating fewer than 80,000 students, yet we pay for school budgets that exceed what we paid when we had 104,000 students. The enrollment numbers are still in decline. Our budgets continue to increase.
Cut that any way you’d like; the trend is still unaffordable.
That same trend is in play in what we pay for health care.
And although legislators don’t set the borrowing rates, they have a profound effect on people’s standard of living. Six years ago the 30-year mortgage rate was roughly 2.9 percent. Today it’s about 6.7 percent. On a $400,000 mortgage, the difference is about $950 a month, or over $11,000 a year. Add consistent increases in the property tax to pay for our schools, and you’re talking about real money.
Voters aren’t stupid, which explains the growing chorus to cut spending and taxes. People have been nibbled to death. And, as nice as most Vermonters are, they are getting to the point where they are inclined to slap the hand that reaches into their pocket.
Can you blame them? Here’s the challenge: It’s one thing to call for reduced spending or lower taxes. It’s another to identify which tax and by how much, or which programs can manage with less.
We’re in the midst of a campaign. We’re waiting.
by Emerson Lynn
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here