One out of every 10 households in Vermont receives help from the federal government to help pay their heating and cooling costs. The $20 million program is called the Low-Income Energy Assistance Program, better known as LIHEAP. For anyone familiar with Vermont’s winters, its continuance is a matter of life and death.
As obvious as that is, the Trump administration says the program is unnecessary and is in the process of eliminating it. The president has already closed down the Division of Energy Assistance and its employees have been fired.
The reason for the program’s elimination is two-fold: first is the belief that energy prices will drop as the administration works to expand fossil fuel production; second is a 15-year-old report citing the program’s “waste, fraud and abuse.”
Contrary to President Trump’s claims otherwise the price of energy has yet to noticeably decline, and no one expects it to by the time the summer’s heat hits, or even by next winter’s cold. And the plan if energy prices don’t decline?
Mr.Trump doesn’t say. Just trust him that they will.
The use of the 15-year-old study also begs a reexamination. The problems that plagued the program almost two decades ago are no longer relevant. Whereas the LIHEAP program is used by 10 percent of Vermont’s households, roughly a third of Vermont’s residents are classified as poor or low-income. Our poverty rate is about 10.2 percent. Additionally, 26 percent of Vermont adults can't afford typical household expenses.
In other words, the LIHEAP numbers in Vermont reflect the same cohort that uses other federal assistance programs.
When pressed on the issue, defenders of the administration’s push to end the program say that by law the companies that deliver fuel to our homes aren’t allowed to cut the customer off. If they can’t pay, they can’t pay.
Wrong. Our utilities can’t disconnect people from their power from Nov. 1 to March 31. The rules for propane and heating oil suppliers, however, are not regulated by the Public Utility Commission as the utilities are. Regardless, the money is still owed. It’s still a debt for the homeowner and not paying the bill could negatively affect the homeowner’s credit.
The administration’s last defense is that it’s not a federal issue but one that should be handled by each state.
So the taxpayers in Vermont are supposed to dig down into their pockets for $20 million each year? As a country, we’re supposed to pony up $400 million?
The LIHEAP program has been in effect since 1981 when Republican Ronald Reagan was president. Mr. Reagan was a critic of federal spending in general but supported the LIHEAP program because it gave the states more control over how to help low-income residents belabored by high energy costs.
The needs have not changed over the program’s 44 years. And they are particularly acute in the country’s northern states where energy costs are high and winter can be, and most often is, brutal. Support for the program has historically been bipartisan, enjoying widespread support for a simple reason: to not support it puts the elderly, individuals with disabilities, families with young children, and the poor at risk.
For 44 years we’ve been better than that.
There are countless ways to reduce federal spending. Turning off the heat, or the air conditioner isn’t one of them.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here