Scott, Obama agree: Get rid of housing regs

Posted

Former President Barack Obama has an unlikely friend in Vermont when it comes to the “hot button” issue of housing shortages. That would be Gov. Phil Scott who said Mr. Obama was spot on in arguing for an end to “outdated” housing market regulations in his speech at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago on Tuesday. 

The governor was in Rutland this week talking about the same housing issues and how Mr. Obama addressed them. “He’s [Obama] looking across the country and seeing the same thing we’re seeing here in Vermont.”  What they see is a need that goes beyond increasing appropriations and dabbling with nonprofits that specialize in affordable housing. Both individuals stress the need to rework/ditch the regulations that make housing developments so expensive.

Vermont’s Legislature advertised its intention to do just that last session when it passed H.667, and when it overrode the governor’s veto of the bill. The bill was a session-long effort to convince Vermonters that its 200-page bill would make the difference Vermont needed to make. 

It will not. As the governor has made clear, the bill will do little to meet Vermont’s 45,000 home deficit but will do a lot to expand the jurisdiction of Act 250, the state’s land use planning law. The legislation does focus on making it easier to build within our cities and towns, it does not allow for the scale of housing development that would be necessary to dent the state’s housing needs. Not even close.

Mr. Scott had the same thought Mr. Obama expressed: “When there’s a state of emergency, you have to do some things that are uncomfortable. You have to bypass regulations to take care of people.”

So is there an emergency, or isn’t there?

There is, and it’s worse in Vermont than in most other states. When we talk about Vermont’s healthcare crisis, one of the key weaknesses is the inability of hospitals to find housing for their employees. When we talk about education and the decline of our school-aged population, we talk about how difficult it is to find housing that people can afford. When we talk about our stagnant population numbers, we talk about housing. When we talk about the homeless, it becomes a conversation about where to put them. When we talk about the difficulty of attracting people to live and work in Vermont, it becomes an issue of finding a home [almost impossible] that is affordable for the average worker [also impossible.]

So, yes, we have a crisis. But we have a Legislature that’s been cowed by environmentalists who may agree that there is a need for housing, but want the development to happen slowly and within designated growth areas. When the bill passed the Legislature’s public relations machine went to work, claiming an “historic” leap forward in addressing the state’s housing crisis. 

Mr. Scott has hit the campaign trail saying it has not, that the Legislature’s pretense is making things worse by shifting the attention away from the issue.

Mr. Obama said much the same thing: “We need to chart a new way forward…we need to build more units and clear the way some of the outdated laws and regulations that made it harder to build homes for working people.”

The former president was painting a picture of need that stretched from coast to coast, but he could have been speaking to Vermonters directly. 

It’s not an issue to be addressed by increased appropriations. We can’t afford the money that would demand.  It’s an issue that has to be dealt with through reduced regulation at a meaningful level. It’s an issue that begs for some creative perception-changing efforts that would push us toward denser living patterns and new ways to build manufactured housing developments that are efficient, attractive, a third the cost of a regular home, and something that creates a sense of community, battling Vermont’s widespread sense of loneliness and disengagement.

But before any of this can be done, we first need to accept the state’s housing issues for what they are, a crisis of over-riding importance. Problems cannot be solved if people aren’t aware they exist. The governor is pushing in that direction, our legislators need to admit their shortcomings and do the same.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here