School spending is up, so what's gotten us there, and why?

Posted

In the weeks leading up to the Town Meeting day in 2014, Gov. Peter Shumlin urged voters to oppose their school budgets knowing how untenable the increase in the property tax rate increase would be to Vermonters. They followed his advice and rejected 41 school budgets which is about quadruple the average.

We were a state in search of an answer to Vermont’s high cost of education. The size of Vermont’s school budgets and the inefficiency of an archaic school system with too many school districts and school boards led to Act 46, which cut the number of school boards by over 150. Voters in 151 districts formed 38 new union school districts. The consolidation worked. The school systems became more efficient and less costly to run.

It’s almost a decade later and we’ve learned efficiency will only get you so far. If schools are asked to do more it will cost more. If our leaders push to expand school lunches at a cost of $29 million, then that money has to come from somewhere. Demanding extra money for schools dealing with inequity issues comes with a cost. If schools need to act as mental health counselors, that, too, comes with a bill. So does the astronomical increase in health care coverage for teachers. Emerging from the disastrous pandemic has left gaping holes in what services schools can and should offer. 

So, understanding our past and our present, it should not be a surprise to read that statewide our schools are pushing for budgets that represent a 12 percent increase. It’s an old story and it can be traced back through each governor for the last half century. We are a rural state with a lot of schools and a dwindling number of students. It’s been a central issue for governors and legislators for a half-century, if not more.

As seen in the two letters in today’s paper, the 12 percent spending increase and the forecast of an 18.5 percent increase in property taxes hit a nerve. How do you maintain the level of education and spend less? And how does a state swallow an 18 percent property tax increase without losing the affordability battle?

It’s a given that the 18.5 percent property tax increase will not happen. The Legislature sets the rate in April and typically what the Legislature does varies from the projections submitted each December. It’s also an election year and the Democrats - who have a supermajority in the Senate and House - don’t want the blame that comes with being responsible for a hefty hike in property taxes.

Gov. Phil Scott has also drawn his line in the sand. He said the projected increase is unacceptable. Full stop. It’s a simple, easy-to-understand political message: He’s the affordable Vermont guy and he knows how to etch a message on the minds of voters. No matter what figure the Legislature settles on it’s likely to be too much for the governor, and he will say so. He can ride that message to the general election should he choose to do so. Property taxes touch everything from housing to employment to our need to grow.

But the larger calling for both the governor and the Legislature is to admit the complexity that accompanies the cost of running our schools. The complicity should also be understood and recognized. Education isn’t a partisan objective. Republicans and Democrats alike listen to the needs of our educators, parents, and students. What comes out of that collective are the budgets we vote on in March and the bills our legislators vote on and our governor signs into law.

A true measure of effectiveness would be for Republicans and Democrats to acknowledge the issues that have gotten us where we are and to figure out how best to reset priorities so that the property tax rate increase will be easier for Vermonters to digest. For example, is now really a good time to be spending millions of dollars in PCB remediations when there is little agreement as to its value or the need for immediate and highly disruptive action?

Education is a complicated issue and, typically, we don’t do complicated. Particularly in election years. The VTNEA has already come out in support of the existing budgets, insisting that we just raise taxes to cover the costs. That’s a “solution” that was dead on arrival for almost all Vermonters. Somewhere between just raising taxes and cutting the projected 18.5 percent increase in property taxes lies a more acceptable answer. But it would be helpful if Vermonters had a better understanding of why we are where we are. That’s something that needs to come from our elected leaders.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here