At this point in the presidential primaries what moves the needle is the image of the warrior, someone not captured by moderation, someone willing to match an impending crisis with a radical solution, someone to whom compromise is weakness. That’s the thought, as least, within the Bernie Sanders’ campaign and among his supporters.
That is on full display with his most recent plan to address climate change. It’s radical, enormously expensive, and, according to the climate science experts, unworkable. Even those climate scientists who believe it’s the issue of our time are not swayed by the Vermont independent’s plan and although polite in their dismissal, their alarm is palpable. They fear the cynicism when Mr. Sanders’ plan is pulled apart and understood to be more a political document than something truly achievable.
It’s a $16 trillion dollar proposal with the promise being that in exactly one decade, 10 years, the country’s renewable power industry would be nationalized, and the electricity we generate and the transportation system we use would be run entirely on wind, solar, geothermal, batteries, etc. And, by the way, the fossil fuel industry will pay the bills, and we are not allowed to use the zero emission nuclear power industry, which presently is responsible for about 20 percent of our energy and 50 percent of our carbon free power.
The political calculation is that the details are unimportant, there is no appetite for nuance, what is important is creating and then sustaining the perception of absolutism. Mr. Sanders has set the standard by which he, and his supporters, will judge others.
Mr. Sanders is employing the same strategy with health care. His Medicare-for-All quickly became the standard for the party’s left wing. It’s what he uses to separate himself from Joe Biden. Elizabeth Warren signed on initially, then developed her own plan, then, last week, split her plan in two, going slowly at first, evolving to a Medicare-for-All later. The Sanders campaign pounced, spear in hand, screaming that Ms. Warren’s go slow approach [which is anything but] was a betrayal to the cause; in Bernie’s world it’s all or nothing.
For Vermonters, this is not news. He’s championed an all or nothing crusade for the last 40 years. It comes as naturally as drawing the next breath. [Only faster.]
To Mr. Sanders the details truly don’t matter. Nuance is for losers, it’s another way of saying something can’t be done. And it’s confusing.
There is something to that. Making a difference is part inspiration.
But, as the cliche goes, most of making a difference comes from perspiration, the hard work of actually forging change, picking up the hammer and pounding the heated metal into the shoe the horse can use.
What should concern anyone watching this week’s impeachment hearing is the unalloyed need for the Democrats to put forth their very best in opposing this president. It all transpires in less than a year. The first primary votes are a couple of months away and the battle — pushed by Mr. Sanders — is on the left.
Common wisdom holds that whomever wins the primary shifts toward the center for the general election. Is there anyone who truly believes Mr. Sanders will find moderation as the path he finds most comfortable? When Mr. Sanders ran in 2016 his followers sat the election out. They could not abide Hillary Clinton. We have Donald Trump as a result. And Mr. Sanders’ proposals were far less aggressive then than they are today.
By pushing the debate so far left, does it not terrify those who are most interested in defeating Mr. Trump next November? Mr. Sanders would essentially nationalize health care and the power industry, dismantle the financial system as we know it and launch a massive investment in rebuilding the nation’s infrastructure. All at the same time. That’s just for starters. There is merit in all of what he seeks to accomplish, but feeding on the extremes does little but give Mr. Trump a inexcusably easy script to follow in the general election. This is why we are seeing continued interest by people like Michael Bloomberg and, most recently, Deval Patrick, the popular former governor of Massachusetts, one of only two African Americans ever to be elected to govern a state.
They see little inspiration coming from Mr. Biden, and they see nothing but extremism and divisiveness coming from Mr. Sanders and Ms. Warren. The specter of another four years of Mr. Trump haunts them, and that fear is pushed to its outer limits when Mr. Sanders paints his campaign, and perhaps the party, into a smaller and smaller corner.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here