S.325 a better approach to housing, Vt.

Posted

 When the Legislature passed Act 181 two years ago, it was promoted as a necessary correction to Vermont’s heralded Act 250 law passed in 1970. It would make growth easier, more affordable, and focused near the state’s existing infrastructure. It would also dramatically increase environmental protection in ecologically sensitive areas.

Gov. Phil Scott vetoed the bill. He said it was too restrictive, too ambitious, and counterproductive to the state’s need to grow and to build more homes. His veto was overridden by the Democratically-controlled legislature. 

Two years later, the law is being reviewed by the Legislature with a perspective more akin to the governor’s liking. Housing is pricier and more scarce than ever. The state’s population is shrinking, and rural Vermont is becoming more concerned that it will fall victim to the law’s rules long before anyone is certain what the impact of the rules will be. 

This uncertainty applies to the so-called “tier-3” lands that the law seeks to protect, and the 800-foot rule stipulating that Act 250 review is triggered for any development that has a driveway longer than 800 feet. [As one rural Vermonter commented, they measure things in acres, not feet, in the hinterlands.]

The governor remains opposed to the law and wants it repealed. 

That’s unlikely and for good reason. The law has important provisions that need to be acted upon, namely incentives for growth to be focused near the state’s growth centers, places that have infrastructure and municipal services. It’s also important to protect the state’s forests and critical natural resources. 

The good news is that the Senate Natural Resources & Energy Committee on Thursday unanimously approved S. 325, which will address most concerns. All “major implementation deadlines” have been pushed back. The road rule has been delayed from this July to January 1, 2030. Tier 3 rulemaking has been delayed until June 30, 2028, and interim housing exemptions are extended until January 1, 2030.

As the committee chairs noted, they are reacting to the need to “slow down, listen to Vermonters, and get the details right.”

That’s a start. As we noted when the bill was passed, it was a monstrous extension of Act 250’s reach and not a “modernization” of the 56-year-old law. Fortunately, the state’s housing crisis has pushed its way into the public’s consciousness, and groups like Let’s Build Homes, shepherded by Miro Weinberger, are making a difference in the seriousness of the conversation. [It helps when Democrats join ranks with those who understand the importance of growth.]

They are bringing attention [and opposition] to any and all regulations that can be viewed as barriers to building new homes, or anything that impedes efforts to bring prosperity to rural Vermont.

That same theme was embraced in an op-ed on Page 7 by St. Albans resident Denise Smith, executive director of the Vermont Council on Rural Development. She asked the fundamental question: “Do we want rural Vermont to operate from scarcity or from abundance and possibility?”

Let’s hope Vermont’s legislators respond appropriately and recast S. 181 in a saner, more productive manner. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here