Ruling restores rights at border

Posted

U.S. District Judge Denise Casper last week ruled that people who cross the border have almost the same Fourth Amendment rights citizens have in their “persons, houses, papers and affects”, and that border agents cannot search people’s electronic devices without reasonable suspicion that the sought after contraband exists.

The case was brought by the Electronic Frontier Foundation and the American Civil Liberties Union, prompted by the upsurge in the number of searches done by federal agents on people’s cell phones and laptops. Last year, according to Sen. Patrick Leahy’s office, there were 33,000 searches by Customs and Border Protection on electronic devices, which was a four-fold increase over the number of similar searches in 2015.

Mr. Leahy, who is the senior member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, has taken special notice of the increase in the searches and continues to push legislation that would require probable cause and a search warrant for these searches to be conducted. He has also introduced legislation that would limit how far from the border customs and border authorities could operate. Currently, their jurisdiction extends 100 miles from the border, which in Vermont’s case would be three miles south of Middlebury. Mr. Leahy’s bill would cut that to 25 miles, or from the border to just before Milton.

These new threats to privacy are part of the mismatch between past constitutional standards and the highly technological world we live in. Today, most of a person’s life can be examined by opening a person’s cell phone and laptop. Any reasonably intelligent person could quickly see the contacts, the photos, schedules, emails, special interests, birthdays, political leanings, etc. It’s a level of information that, a generation ago, was never available to border officials. Customs officials understand this as well, and they also understand that their authority to investigate is almost without limit. They understand precisely the amount of information a person’s digital device contains. And, to this point, they were operating within their bounds in their searches.

What Judge Casper did was to recognize the difference between the past and the present and to bring clarity to the Constitution’s Fourth Amendment protections in a 21st century world ruled by technology.

From the ACLU’s point of view, the judge’s decision did not go far enough. As with Mr. Leahy, they want a law, or a court ruling, that requires border officials to have probable cause and a warrant before a person’s electronic devices can be examined. Judge Casper only ruled that “reasonable suspicion” was necessary.

Her ruling is a big step in the right direction, one that needs to be pushed forward in Congress by Vermont’s delegation, along with other states that share an international border.

And while we recognize that only a small percentage of those who cross the border are ever subjected to such searches, it’s not about numbers, it’s not about the odds of being stopped, it’s about an officer searching you for no defensible reason, and doing so in ways that weren’t imaginable a generation ago. For people in Vermont it’s unsettling to think you might be searched, that you would sit for hours as your phone and laptop were gone through contact by contact, issue by issue, photo by photo. We have a disproportionate number of Vermonters who go back and forth across the border regulary, and a number of Quebecers who do the same. It’s accepted that a secure border is necessary, few argue otherwise. But it’s not accepted that just because we’ve managed to tuck our lives into tiny little digital boxes that they are now open for border authorities to flip through as well. Just because they can, or could.

Judge Casper has pushed us in the right direction.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here