Operation Warp Speed was President Trump’s unqualified success in his first term, as COVID-19 turned our world upside down. The mRNA vaccine saved millions of lives. It was produced in months compared to the years predicted, and is regarded as one of the most efficacious vaccines ever produced. This is Mr. Trump’s victory, which begs the question: Why would he allow U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to cut roughly $500 million in mRNA vaccine contracts? Why limit the reach of a vaccine that could be used for other respiratory diseases?
Politics, in a word.
The president sees the odds of another Covid-like pandemic being small and, for the moment, he gets to ride Mr. Kennedy’s anti-vaxxer wave.
To say that’s unfortunate is a massive understatement. Particularly for a state like Vermont, which has a large elderly population. The mRNA vaccine is also proving successful in dealing with the flu, which kills close to 100 Vermonters each year. It’s even showing early promise in treating cancer and aiding gene editing therapies.
Why would any administration distance itself from medical progress that could save lives? Why forgo the chance to strengthen public health and take credit for innovation? Isn’t that central to the MAHA movement?
Apparently, not.
As the Kennedy movement expands, there is a growing “public health libertarianism” that is arming itself against the left-leaning public health community. Public health is becoming something pushed by the right. It is focused on personal choices. Obesity, for example, can be handled, they contend, by the individual through diet, a change in culture, and exercise. We can be in charge of our own health and celebrate our successes as part of our elevated behavioral virtues.
Not only is that elitism of the highest order, it’s completely wrong. If the battle against obesity could be handled through self-help, it would not be the issue it is. It can’t. It’s costing us mightily. Ninety cents out of every dollar spent on health care goes to managing chronic conditions, which, by definition, are controllable. Obesity is a major part of that cost. So, all we have to do is eat better, run a couple of miles each day, and address some of our behavioral issues, and obesity disappears?
We had hoped for a better response from Mr. Kennedy. Hoped, not expected. Isn’t his extensive use of testosterone supplements contrary to the right’s libertarian beliefs? And if he’s truly committed to “Making America Healthy Again,” why would he not use the power of his agency [and the Trump administration] to use GLP-1s - a true “miracle drug” to reduce obesity?
The makers of the obesity drugs are on the cusp of making the GLP-1 into pill forms, which is an order of magnitude cheaper to produce than injectables. Imagine the benefit if the government subsidized the distribution and manufacturing of the drugs. Think of the impact that might have on the nation’s health care costs.
But there could hardly be a drug that is more counter to a philosophy that rewards only being responsible for our own well-being.
Is that where we’re headed? Raising the level of mistrust we have in our scientific community, believing that, as individuals, we are better able to manage our own health? Our vaccination rates continue to decline, which, of course, raises the probability of an outbreak of those diseases the vaccinations were designed to suppress. All because we have Mr. Kennedy and his followers suggesting the safety of the vaccines is questionable. It’s a spin-off of the libertarian belief that you can do the homework and make the correct decision yourself…because you looked it up. You asked Chat GPT.
When Mr. Kennedy was nominated for the position by Mr. Trump, there was the thought that he might not be as bad as feared, that common sense would prevail, that he would take on the food industry, keep the scientific community content, and not cut off the research and development pipelines that have kept us the world’s leader in all things medical.
Wrong.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here