Regulators give us a little hope for healthcare outlook

Posted

This is a better late than never story.

Last week, the Vermont Department of Financial Regulation [DFR] issued an order to put itself at the center of any contract negotiations between Vermont’s hospitals and the state’s two insurers - MVP and BlueCross Blue Shield of Vermont. 

The order does three things: it helps make sure health care premiums don’t continue to soar, it helps make sure the insurers stay in business, and it serves as a backup to the Green Mountain Care Board’s mission to redo Vermont’s health care system. It lends confidence to Vermonters concerned about the viability of the state’s hospitals.

The order came about after the Liaison Team - established by the Legislature - saw that BCBS of Vermont and the University of Vermont Health Network could not overcome their differences.  They could not agree on what was needed to ultimately lower commercial health insurance rates, which are the nation’s highest.

That’s not unusual. Hospitals want to keep what they can, and insurers have to charge enough to stay in business. But typically, an understanding is eventually reached. In this case, it was not. The Liaison Team, seeing no alternative, stepped in with the recommendation that a third party - the Department of Financial Regulation - formalize its role as the negotiator between insurers and hospitals. The department - led by Mr. Kaj Samsom - requires the insurers to verify that the final agreements lead to a “material reduction” in commercial healthcare premiums.

That gives the upper hand to the insurers. It also puts the Green Mountain Care Board in the position of being able to support the negotiations with its power to regulate budgets.

The timing was essential. BCBS of Vermont has lost a boatload of money - almost $152 million over the last four years. It’s also the state’s largest insurer. Without them, the state would be in a mess. Vermont’s health care premiums are also the nation’s highest and, for example, four times what the people of New Hampshire pay and double the national average.

Mr. Samsom was quoted as saying, “There was a lot of hope by all parties that in the regular cadence of negotiation, Blue Cross and MVP could prevent some of the necessary insurance rate increases, through negotiated cost reductions with providers. All parties are trying to find common ground, but the fact is that they’ve failed.”

The Liaison Team, led by Gov. Phil Scott’s former chief of staff and head of Health and Human Services Mike Smith, stepped in, asking DFR to exercise its authority on a more public level. Mr. Smith also recommended that BCBS of Vermont have an “overseer/monitor” for the next 12 months. That’s smart. We can’t wake up one morning to learn that the insurer is out of business and Vermont has no plan to fix things.

In truth, that should have been done long ago. Our health care system is at risk. We thought it would take care of itself like it always has. Vermont’s hospitals are like Vermont’s schools. They are institutional, they’ve always been, and we always thought they would remain as they were, solid financially and with top-tier ratings.

It worked. Until it didn’t. We’re no longer the best in healthcare or education, and we are more expensive in each sector than most all states. Now, we are having to adjust. And on a big scale. Perhaps the encouraging part is that we have people who are assuming responsibility for the positions we are in and what needs to be done to move to firmer ground, to regain the success and stability that was once ours. 

That involvement from our regulators - Mr. Smith, Owen Foster of the Green Mountain Care Board, and Mr. Samsom needs to be public. We need to know why we are here and what’s being done to get us to a better, more affordable, and safer place.

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here