The voters of Calais and Worceser sent a message to the rest of Vermont Tuesday when they overwhelmingly voted against closing two community elementary schools in the Washington Central Unified Union School District.
The two schools have suffered steep declines in the number of students; each has fewer than 100, and one of the schools’ kindergarten classes has seven students, a worrisome indicator of what lies ahead for the schools. That didn’t concern the voters. They wanted their schools to remain open, no matter the cost, no matter the predicted decline in the number of students, no matter the decline in test scores.
The problem, of course, is that the taxpayers of Calis and Worcester aren’t the only ones saddled with the cost of keeping two schools open that should be closed. It’s a tax picked up by all Vermont taxpayers.
Vermont’s challenge was articulated by Andera Tucker and Anthony House, a couple from Texas who moved to Calais for “the small state feel, the small school down the street feel.” The Vermont Digger story quoted Ms. Tucker as saying she hopes “our state representatives are paying attention to what rural Vermonters are communicating with these recent elections. Our small schools are an asset to invest in and leverage in response to a declining population.”
Ms. Tucker is incorrect. And it will be a disaster if we don’t make structural changes to our educational system. We have too many schools, too few students, and too many school districts. We will never reduce costs, we will never raise our test scores, and we will never improve our educational infrastructure if all things remain as they are.
And, to directly address the couple’s point, families from other states are highly unlikely to move to Calais just because voters kept the school open. To the contrary, keeping the school open raises costs and reduces educational opportunity for the students. Why would people move there when they see sky-high costs and a questionable future for the school?
They wouldn’t.
The story isn’t confined to Calais or Worcester. It’s rural Vermont’s story. We’re losing population. We’re getting older. And our costs continue to soar. We have 255 municipalities, many of which want to keep things as they are. We have over 300 public schools, each of whom have its defenders. We have the nation’s highest student-to-teacher ratio, the nation’s highest number of teachers and staff per 100 pupils, and we rank #2 or #3 in education spending per student.
Tuesday’s poll results in Calais and Worcester may offer momentary elation for those who oppose change. It is not a recipe for sustainability, let alone growth.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here