A “healthy” percentage of the Ben & Jerry’s ice cream comes from its St. Albans plant, hence, a solid percentage of the milk the company uses comes from Franklin County farms. Last week the company was sued because the cows producing the milk aren’t “happy cows.” In fact, the suit’s complaint, in the main, is that today’s Ben & Jerry’s, owned by Unilever, isn’t like the old Ben & Jerry’s when it was actually operated by the company’s two originators.
The suit was filed by James Elhers, executive director of Lake Champlain International, and a former gubernatorial candidate in the 2016 Democratic primary. [He finished a distant second to Christine Hallquist.]
It’s not the first time Ben & Jerry’s has been sued, and for basically the same reasons. The Organic Consumers Association made the same claims a year or so ago, and the case is still pending. The group contends Ben & Jerry’s isn’t as environmentally friendly as it says it is.
There is a degree of truth to the claim if the standard is to be absolute. Ben and Jerry’s has never said that every single drop of milk they use comes from wholly contended cows, on wholly contented farms, on wholly contented grain and grass. No ice cream manufacturer could make that claim. But Ben & Jerry’s is particularly vulnerable because of their founders and the socially good image they used to expand their following. Unilever, one of the planet’s largest companies, struggles to mimic the same ah shucks behavior.
Why, then, would Mr. Elhers push basically the same sort of law suit that was filed by the Organic Consumers Association?
Several reasons: It doesn’t cost much to file a suit, it gets him and his organization some attention, which helps to raise money from supportive advocates, and it’s his basic onslaught against dairy farms, particularly the large ones that might be sending effluent into the state’s waters.
So, why not sue?
By now, however, the jig should be up. Every drop of milk Ben & Jerry’s uses could be as pure as driven snow and there would still be the Jim Elhers of the world upset that a large corporation owns what was once an ice cream shop run out of a garage - 41 years ago.
But Ben and Jerry sold the company because they did not have the resources or the knowledge to grow the brand. They also became wealthy, selling the company in 2000 for $326 million. And, unlike many entrepreneurs who sell their start-ups, the two are still associated with the product and its socially-driven message. Not a bad gig.
The ensuing 19 years have been good ones for the ice cream maker and better yet for St. Albans and our farmers. The brand continues to be strong; Unilever owns roughly 25 percent of the ice cream market world wide and Ben & Jerry’s usually ranks somewhere in the top five brands, depending on the year. According to Forbes, sales have topped $1.25 billion annually. A little sliver of that comes back to St. Albans and our farmers.
Is the company profiting from a long-ago image of social do-goodism? Let’s hope so. But truth be told, the reason most people buy Ben & Jerry’s ice cream is because it tastes good. Better than most. If you were to poll the first 100 Ben & Jerry’s consumers in Austin, Texas, or Paris, or London, or almost anywhere else in the world the brand is sold, it’s a safe bet that an overwhelming majority don’t know who Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield are, let alone their social or political values.
There is a bit of irony in all this. After all, ice cream is loaded with sugar and then there’s the butter fat, and there’s the nation’s obesity rate.
But Mr. Elhers is going after Ben & Jerry’s because the cows aren’t happy. You can’t make this up.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here