It’s not often that a public meeting on a housing project attracts a standing room only crowd. But that was what happened with the St. Albans development review board in late August.
The board was reviewing the application of a proposed 80-unit housing complex on Parsons Avenue. The proposal had not only prompted over 200 people to sign a petition in opposition to the project, but a good share of them took the time to show up at the meeting. And wanted time to speak. That’s unusual. Not often do such development proposals spark that level of opposition.
And they were not to be deterred.
Good. It’s always encouraging to see people get publicly involved. It makes for better planning. It sets a higher standard for the sort of development that promotes long-term growth.
And that’s not what the opposition saw when they reviewed the 80-unit housing complex - called Alton’s Landing - by Concordia Holdings, owned by Jake Tardiff and his mother Bonnie Turner of Milton.
What they saw was something out of scale for their middle-class, single-home residences. The developers were proposing that the 80 units be built on a 10-acre plot with parking for 172 cars, little to no green space, and no storage or garages. Parsons Avenue is also a very narrow street, raising concerns about traffic caused by such an increase in density.
It’s easy to typify the opposition as little more than the NIMBY crowd - in favor of growth but just not in their backyards.
That’s not what this is. Most of us understand the importance of growth and how important it is to create the housing necessary to fuel the economy. So do they. The people who showed up aren’t opposed to new housing. What they are opposed to is a housing development wildly out of character with their own neighborhoods.
Finding that balance is part of the development review board’s responsibility. Leaving questions unanswered or ignoring the impact of an unwelcome housing development makes it easier for poorly planned projects in the future.
The developers seem to get a whiff of how serious the opposition was, thereby reducing their ask from 80 units down to 56. [Which is still a ton for a 10-acre lot.]
But there are additional questions that need to be addressed before the next development review board meeting on October 9.
• Why has the fire department expressed a concern about the development and how that might affect its ability to do its job? How is the issue to be resolved?
• How troublesome could the traffic be on Parsons Avenue? Has a traffic study been done?
• What can be done to absolutely guarantee that the units would never end up being Section 8 housing?
• Does a 56-home development really complement the character of the existing neighborhood?
• Has the state investigated the property to see if part of it would be considered a wetland?
• The homes are small - roughly 1,200 square feet - with no garages or storage, yet they are asking $350,000 per home. Is that realistic? What happens if they can’t sell them at that price?
Clearly, the proposed development is in the early stages. But, as the neighborhood’s opponents have made clear, it should not proceed any further until the questions are answered and the opponents are confident the development not only fills a need but does so in a way that makes their neighborhoods a better place to live.
There are a number of proposed housing developments in Greater St. Albans that have been built, or are on the verge of being built, all addressing the state’s desperate need to expand its housing supply. Generally speaking, they have met the public’s acceptance. The developers of the proposed Alton’s Landing need to do the same. That’s all the opposition asks.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here