In the 2023 legislative session, Vermont’s lawmakers put into statute their plan to reduce the state’s emissions by establishing clean heat standards. In short, the purpose is to get Vermonters to burn “clean” heat. The question then, and now, is at what cost.
To pass the law - and to overcome Gov. Phil Scott’s veto - legislators agreed to give the Public Utility Commission enough time to examine how the program would be put in place, what the net benefits would be, and how much it would cost. The Legislature wanted the information when it convened the 2025 session - four months from now.
The Public Service Department hired the consultants to do the necessary work, but the information shared with the public has been spotty at best, and confusing, which has led to misinterpreted claims on both sides of the argument.
Last week the consultants filed the conclusion of its pre-implementation study, noting that its projected cost would be just shy of $10 billion, half of what had been speculated in an earlier report. Last week’s report also noted that the program would create over $11 billion in “benefits” and would serve as a key part in helping the state meet its emission requirements as part of the Global Warming Solutions Act.
It may be that the $11 billion in benefits is a tangible thing, after all lowering emissions is an agreed-upon goal in the battle to moderate the effects of global warming. But these benefits need to be explained in greater detail and with far less ambiguity. These “benefits” also need to be detailed beyond emissions. Most Vermonters don’t have a clue about the issue, the suggested benefits, or the costs.
The consultants did put their pens to the question of affordability but were reluctant to put the numbers in a cost-benefit analysis, suggesting that step was above their pay grade.
In a Vermont Digger story Sen. Chris Bray, D-Addison said he would be doing the work to determine whether the cost of implementing the program would be worth it. He responded to earlier speculations of needing to raise the price of heating fuel by $1.70 per gallon as something he would not be interested in.
The hope is that the cost information will be available before the Legislative session begins. Once the session convenes the partisan atmosphere makes it difficult to give the necessary attention to a single issue, like the clean heat standards. The competition for air time becomes part of the legislative din. It makes it difficult for the few reporters who cover the Legislature to adequately describe the proposed law’s details.
Maybe that’s the strategy. But it shouldn’t be. People already have a trust issue with the democratic process. Tucking a discussion like this into the middle of the legislative session is a disservice to the public. It’s also self-defeating in the long term. The more trust elected officials lose the less willing the public is to follow them on future issues.
The clean heat standard is an important piece of legislation. But it needs to be understood if it is to be supported. All the information necessary to determine its cost should be available in short order. That’s when the story should be brought to Vermonters. And that should happen months before the Legislative session begins.
Legislators should trust Vermonters’ ability to determine what is defensible and what is not. Transparency goes a long way.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here