Preparing for a stingy healthcare future

Posted

When the Vermont Legislature passed the budget bill in late May it included what might be called a “we don’t know” provision, a set-aside of about $300 million that could be used to make up for expected cuts in federal funding.

We will need every penny of it, and then some.

The Scott Administration is in the process of assessing how President Trump’s “one big beautiful bill” will affect Vermont. By month’s end, we should have a rough idea of just how deep the hole will be. 

The overriding contributor to our concern is the size of the cuts to Medicaid, the federal program for low-income individuals and families. It’s estimated that the new law’s stricter Medicaid eligibility rules will cost 45,000 Vermonters their health care coverage.

That’s a particularly acute problem for rural states like Vermont because the payer mix is heavily skewed toward Medicaid recipients. Two things happen when someone is kicked off Medicaid: first, they stop getting care, which ultimately means their medical problems get worse, costing more; second, hospitals watch as their uncompensated care costs soar.

The estimate of that lost federal Medicaid funding is roughly $205 million annually.

That’s bad enough. The new law also includes a reduction in what’s called the “provider tax” which is a tax the state levies on Vermont’s hospitals. It’s applied to a hospital’s net patient revenue and collected by the Agency of Human Services. The funds are pooled into the state’s Medicaid budget and used to draw down more federal Medicaid funds. In other words, every dollar collected from hospitals is used by the state to leverage money from the government. 

The extra draw-down from the feds is important to hospitals like Northwestern Medical Center because Medicaid pays lower rates than private insurers. The extra cash helps rural hospitals cover their costs.

The rate of the provider tax varies from state to state, but it’s usually between a low of two percent to a high of six percent. Vermont’s rate is set at six percent, one of the nation’s highest, thus, we are at risk of losing more than most states would lose. The estimate is roughly $200 million each year through 2032.

All of this is happening at the same time Vermont’s healthcare system is in the midst of its own struggle to survive. Particularly our small, rural hospitals, as well as our primary insurer, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont. Remember, too, that the governor signed into law legislation that sets a 2.5 percent reduction in health care costs statewide.

All of this will become painfully apparent next month as our hospitals appear before the state’s regulator, the Green Mountain Care Board, to have their budgets reviewed. [It’s hard to imagine how a hospital can give a very accurate reading of what they face.]

What all of this should make apparent is the bottom-line assessment: there is simply no pot of money available to make these challenges disappear. 

If there is a shred of good news to be found, it’s that the process is drawn out over the decade. And who knows, Congress may wake up to the damage caused, particularly to rural America, and soften its approach. But that doesn’t seem likely. Not anytime soon.

In sum, that puts Vermont in the position of being the backstop for lost Medicaid funding as well as income and food assistance programs such as SNAP. 

Equally, if not more important, is understanding just how pivotal the transformational change in our healthcare system is to its own survival in Vermont. It’s hard to remember when it has been more important to understand why we are where we are and how we can emerge better prepared for a stingy future. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here