Polls show a public tired of incumbents

Posted

When last week’s Green Mountain State poll was released, showing Gov. Phil Scott trailing far-left candidate Amanda Janoo by six points, jaws dropped, particularly among Republicans. How could a political unknown be leading the nation’s most popular governor? 

Several days later, a poll released by Vermont Public showed the opposite. Mr. Scott led Ms. Janoo by a solid 10 percent among likely voters. Still, the 10 percent margin combined with Ms. Janoo’s earlier polling numbers has Republicans on edge. When the gubernatorial campaign began, they expected the governor to coast to victory as he has in his last four elections.

As we’ve said before, voter fatigue is real, no matter the popularity of the person in office. That explains part of the governor’s drop in favorability. We also have a growing percentage of the American public, Republicans included, who think very little of those in office, something that has been amplified by the malignant narcissism of the nation’s president.

It’s hard to blame the voters, which is why they view Republicans and Democrats negatively. How interesting that Mr. Scott and Representative Becca Balint, D-Vt., poll almost the same despite being from opposite parties with opposed political ideals. Has incumbency become a weakness, not a strength?

The issue that has voters aligned, no matter the party and no matter the state, is affordability. That’s been the case since the 2008 financial crisis, which is why Republicans and Democrats alike are more open than ever to more populist ideas. Republicans were the traditional holdouts from anything that challenged free markets, but that’s changing as prices remain high and they watch as the rich continue to prosper while the rest languish. And most voters, frankly, have lost hope that those in power can fix anything that needs fixing.

That said, voters should also feel a sense of frustration that the gubernatorial debate in Vermont is being conducted at such a superficial level. The public is hearing the candidates’ promises on social media but is given almost no analysis of how problems are to be solved, or what a candidate’s suggestions would involve. For example, the Vermont Public poll says 41 percent of Vermonters care more about keeping their property taxes low than keeping public schools in their community. Okay. How does that work? If, as Ms. Janoo suggests, many of the state’s challenges can be met by raising taxes, then who gets taxed, by how much, and where, exactly, does the money go? And does Vermont really have enough rich people to make such a wealth transfer work? As regards Mr. Scott’s positions, if affordability is to be the center of his administration’s next term, then what can we expect that is any different from his last ten years in office?

At this point, it would appear Mr. Scott has the advantage, which is what we’d expect. But it would be a mistake for Republicans to think they needn’t be concerned. Voters are fed up. 

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here