Poll shows gov has not worn out his welcome

Posted

Few things are more important than the person who leads a state, and few things are less surprising than the fact that a strong majority of Vermonters approve of Gov. Phil Scott’s performance in office and want him to run for reelection next year.

The “Green Mountain State Poll” was conducted by the University of New Hampshire and showed that over 60 percent of the 880-person survey approved of the governor’s work, and 57 percent wanted Mr. Scott to sign up for another term.

The results are not surprising or particularly meaningful. The election is more than a year away, and the public has only a meager awareness of any Democrats or Progressives who might decide to run against Mr. Scott.

It’s also anyone’s guess how Vermont will be treated by the Trump administration and how independents and middle-of-the-road Democrats will react to whatever comes next. Thus far, Mr. Scott has acquitted himself relatively well. He continues his arm-length relationship/frustration with the administration, and keeps his focus where it matters most - at home.

What is unusual is Mr. Scott’s longevity. This is his fifth term. Only Gov. Howard Dean has served longer. Most governors have worn out their welcome with the voters by now. When Mr. Scott announced his candidacy for a fifth term, it was widely assumed it would be his last.

That’s the principal reason Vermont Treasurer Mike Pieciak and State Attorney General Charity Clark have taken every opportunity to put their names before the voters for the past 10 months. Both are Democrats. Both are young. Both are responding to the fact that a new generation of political hopefuls is on the horizon. They intend to be among the counted. For them, a first-time run against the governor would be considered a get-acquainted exercise, and not politically suicidal.

It’s anyone’s guess whether Mr. Scott will run for a sixth term. But we do know the Republicans don’t have a strong bench. Lieutenant Governor John Rodgers is not polling well, and he’s the only other Republican elected to a statewide position. If Mr. Scott doesn’t run, the odds are considerable that a Democrat will prevail.

Whether Mr. Scott ultimately runs for office again or not, he’s doing an artful job of neutralizing any potential opposition. The most obvious, is his recent “14-point short-term action plan” to address public safety issues in Burlington, the state’s largest city and the stronghold for Democrats and Progressives.

The governor’s weakest area of support is Chittenden County, where “only” 47 percent of the poll’s respondents said they approved of his job performance. The key issue is public safety. The governor’s plan was developed in conjunction with Burlington Mayor Emma Mulvaney-Stanak, a progressive who has expressed her appreciation for the governor’s support, something he would choose to broadcast should he decide to run again.

What’s interesting about the poll and Mr. Scott is just how strong his support is among those who consider themselves to be to the left of the governor. Of those who considered themselves socialists, 41 percent approved of the governor’s job performance. Thirty-nine percent of Vermont’s Progressives did so. Sixty-four percent of the liberals did, and supportive moderates tallied 95 percent. Seventy percent of the conservatives and 54 percent of the libertarians gave him a thumbs up.

Those are stiff numbers for any Democratic challenger.

Still, the governor has his challenges. He’s in the middle of what could be the most difficult issue of his gubernatorial tenure, which is his effort to redo the state’s educational system, which, in his view, means lowering costs and raising educational standards. He’s also on the leading edge of figuring out how to reduce healthcare costs and how to restructure the state’s healthcare system, so people have access to quality care at an affordable price. Both issues [and affordable housing] are central to the state’s prosperity, and, as governor, he is the one who must shoulder the responsibility for pushing things forward.

That said, any challenger - Mr. Pieciak or Ms. Clark - will have to have answers of their own. It won’t work for them to blame the governor without solutions of their own. Been there, done that.

The October poll is only a point in time, and anything can happen. But for the moment, the governor has yet to wear out his welcome. Far from it.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here