The Legislature is on the verge of passing a bill to allow schools until April 15 to reschedule their budget votes. The bill also repeals a provision of Act 127 that had the perverse effect of encouraging some school districts to inflate their spending. The Legislature’s hope is that the school districts in question will be kind to taxpayers by redoing their budgets and cutting the amount proposed to be spent.
At this point, no one knows how many schools will actually elect to redo their budgets. The guess is not enough to make a big difference. What we do know is that our school boards are in an untenable position. They have soldiered through one of the most difficult budget environments on record. To redo their budgets and to postpone the Town Meeting Day vote puts their relationship with the voters at risk. For this reason and others, all the school districts in Franklin County will put their budgets before the voters as they typically do on Town Meeting Day.
If a majority of the state’s school budgets pass the Legislature has but one tool left to reduce the expected double-digit property tax increase. That is to find other revenue sources. But that’s a just a shift in which pocketbook to pick, and there are not enough pocketbooks in Vermont to make a meaningful difference. Raising additional taxes is also a politically precarious thing to do in an election year.
It also misses the point.
We are where we are not because of a difficult budget environment. We are where we are because we don’t have an established policy on how we educate our students and at what cost. We are where we are because we have no leadership on the issue.
There were two quotes this week that should give us pause.
The first came from Norwich Rep. Rebecca Holcombe, former Vermont Secretary of Education: “I can come up with at least $100 million in state programs that school boards did not get to vote on that we put into their budgets and that we’re now about to punish them for.”
The second came from Rep. Peter Conlon, chair of the House Education Committee, who said: “We’re at a major inflection point, crisis point, crossroads - whatever we want to call it. We need to do more than just this one year fix. We need to start having pretty broad conversations.”
The crisis before us is of our own making. We legislate - and spend - without any thought of attached value. It took the threat of a 20 percent property tax increase to focus the public’s attention. Legislators soon followed the crowd.
The question to ask is why Vermont’s educational system has no champions. Why is this happening to us? Why don’t legislators have the same interest in our schools as they have for the environment, affordable housing, drug addiction, climate change, or diversity, equality, and inclusion? Are Ms. Holcombe and Mr. Conlon the only ones in Montpelier who recognize the threats that face our schools? Are they the only ones willing and able to speak out?
If you think the budget challenges are limited to this budget year, think again. It’s just beginning. We still have $6 billion in unmet school construction needs. We still face the untold multi-million dollar cost of dealing with PCBs in our schools [which the state now wants to slow down because of a lack of funds and perhaps because it’s one of the most idiotic pursuits ever.] And remember that whatever budgets pass this year become the base for next year.
It is complicated. And controversial. And expensive. A good educational system is all that. And more. It is also the most vital thing a state offers its citizens. It is how we build for the future.
The bottom line is this: Nothing of importance gets done without leadership. No challenge is met through silence. But that’s where we rest. We have no leadership. The silence is deafening. The consequence of inaction mounts.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here