Our schools: Act now, avoid potential chaos mid-December

Posted

In mid-December Vermonters will be given some “short-term cost containment considerations” to prevent what happened this year from happening next, which means ways to cut school spending, sparing Vermonters another year of double-digit property tax increases.

The suggestions will come from the Commission on the Future of Public Education in Vermont, created by the Legislature this past session with instructions to examine how Vermont’s education funding system works and how it can be improved. The final report is to be issued by December 2025.

The newly appointed commission could begin its meetings this month but is more likely to start the process in September. Most school boards will have worked their way through their budgets just about the time the commission offers any of its suggestions in December, raising the potential for some chaotic times for our school districts, and a sense of alarm for Vermonters anxious about future property tax hikes.

Once again, we’re squeezing too much into a short window of time, which raises the odds of little to nothing being accomplished and puts at risk the public’s confidence in the newly appointed Commission

That makes no sense.

As we have argued before, school districts have the vast majority of next year’s budgets available now. They should be asked to present what they have available with their best guess estimates as to what their final budgets will be. That will give the commission a better understanding of the tasks ahead. It would allow the public to lead, to be more proactive, instead of reactive.

The difference between this proposal and what’s being considered by the commission is roughly five months. Which is forever.  If our school districts are forced to wait until mid-December to digest, and then react to the commission’s “short-term cost containment” ideas, they will find themselves squabbling over the holidays with no time left before the Legislature convenes in early January.

Why pick a path that rushes a complicated process, limits public participation, and makes success less likely?

Given the public’s response to this July’s 13.8 percent increase in property taxes, the commission and our legislators should be laser-focused on how best to begin their mission, after all, being responsible for the future of education in Vermont is a heady task, to say the least. Make an early mistake and any further progress is hobbled. 

The most visible concern for Vermonters is their property tax bill. This year was a shock. They will want to know that next year’s property tax bill will not be a repeat of this year’s. But to get from here to there means the commission will need to understand how the public is reacting to educational reform in general, and how our educational system can be rejiggered to better align with the community’s values and understanding. They will need a better understanding of how we can pair educational outcomes to existing resources.

But so much of what the commission needs to do is to learn the best way to sell what it’s pushing, to get the public to buy in. To do that means involving the public early and often. That means today, not mid-December.

by Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here