Green Mountain Care Board Chairman Kevin Mullin last week told OneCare Vermont executives he was concerned that “if you [OneCare] don’t start telling your story, there’s not going to be a story left to tell.”
OneCare, the accountable care organization that manages the state’s all payer health care system, should not have be told twice.
It’s a complicated organization, one whose purpose and structure is not understood by the general public. It’s also got a $1.4 billion budget, which makes it an easy target. It’s part of the health care system, dominated by the University of Vermont Medical Center, which makes it even an easier target.
That’s what’s happened. As OneCare made its budget request before the GMCB accompanying news accounts were highly misleading; the resulting narrative has been one that questions OneCare’s direction and success.
The weakness of the reporting is two-fold: First, simply saying OneCare’s budget is $1.4 billion, and nothing else, gives readers the impression the money is all OneCare’s. It’s not. 98 percent of that $1.4 billion is pass through money that goes to the hospitals aligned with OneCare. The money reflects hospital budgets that have already been approved by the GMCB. OneCare’s budget is roughly $19 million, or about two percent of that $1.4 billion. That’s a distinction the media is not making, which is misleading.
Second, is questioning OneCare’s success on the prevention front, reporting it hasn’t shown much progress. That supposition, of course, is ludicrous. No one who has even the remotest idea about health care prevention expects to be able to see results within the first several years. It takes years for the health care prevention efforts to show any demonstrable benefit. And OneCare is just getting started.
OneCare Vermont’s purpose is to change the state’s fee-for-service system to a capitation system in which hospitals are paid based on the people served. It’s that change that will gradually force the system to focus on prevention because hospitals will be not bill patients for every service offered. The incentive shifts from a billing effort to one that promotes a healthier population.
Ultimately, that’s the surest way to lower health care costs. If fewer people are sick, the usage rate declines.
Understanding this, and defending the approach is the most important health care initiative before us. As Mr. Mullin said, there is “no plan B.”
The challenge for OneCare is that its defenders are seen as people [and institutions] pushing for their self-interests. At the center of OneCare is the University of Vermont Medical Center, with its executives, and a 10,000 person workforce. The Vermont health care system in total is arguably the largest economic force in the state. But with size comes vulnerability; it’s easy to create the impression that OneCare [and the system it represents] is controlled by the few people at the top of Vermont’s health care pyramid.
The story that is not being told is that this new payment model is what could ultimately give Vermonters the best care at the lowest price. It’s the only model in the country that is actually breaking from a system largely viewed as hobbled beyond repair. This is the issue dominating the presidential debate and we’re sitting here in Vermont with the closest thing to a Medicare-for-all plan in the nation. And, by the way, we all know the chances of the Medicare-for-all approach has zero chance of being implemented any time soon. Meanwhile, we’re midway in the process of having something put in place that could actually work. Now. Today.
The frustration felt by Mr. Mullin is unusual, to say the least. Normally regulators would refrain from telling those they regulate what is in their best interest. Mr. Mullin is watching in frustration because he knows the value of what lies ahead; he’s scratching his head wondering why an organization of OneCare’s sophistication is allowing its narrative to be controlled by others who know far less.
This is happening on several fronts, education being the other. Those in the position of leading don’t step forward because of the exposure that comes with a high profile. They cede the lead to those who have no stake in the outcome, but who want to curry the benefit of being seen as the people who take someone, or some cause, down.
Sadly, it’s become such that people would rather see something fall apart rather than take the risk inherent in assume the profile necessary to get the job done. It’s a horrible way to address the crucial issues before us.
In OneCare’s case its not Vicki Loner, OneCare’s CEO, who should be solely responsible for telling OneCare’s story. It’s the entire health care system. They are in the same group, focused on the same cause, with the same hoped-for outcome. When OneCare is attacked, the system is attacked. When the facts are twisted, the system needs to untwist them. Unapologetically.
When Mr. Mullin takes the unusual step of advocating for a company he regulates he’s sounding an alarm that should be heard by anyone interested in better health care, and in a system that bends health care costs though reduced usage.
It’s insane to allow that message be hijacked by people who don’t have Vermont’s best interests in mind.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here