One year superintendent terms? Not smart.

Posted

There are smart ways to pick your battles, and there are ways that are not so smart. Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders picked the latter this week when she told Vermont’s school districts looking for superintendents that they could only fill the positions for a year.

The ostensible purpose is Ms. Saunders’ continuing effort to push consolidation of the state’s school districts, which is also the goal of her boss, Gov. Phil Scott. There are several challenges with Ms. Saunders’ efforts. First, the Legislature passed, and the governor signed, legislation that would give school districts the option to be part of a plan to consolidate. Mergers were not to be forced. Second, limiting a new superintendent to a year’s tenure almost guarantees that the person hired will be less than the quality required. Third, it’s questionable legally whether Ms. Saunders has the authority to tell school boards what the terms of employment will be for superintendents.

Part of the issue is also just common sense; who would ever agree to be the superintendent of a school district if they knew they would be out of a job 12 months later? Probably no one who has the skills and experience districts need to run their schools in today’s quickly changing world. 

Ms. Saunders has made it clear that school district boards should consider “the work that will need to be accomplished over the next year, including planning for potential mergers and other changes resulting from statewide education transformation.”

Not only is Ms. Saunders getting ahead of herself, but limiting incoming superintendents to a 12-month stint will likely complicate any consolidation plan Ms. Saunders may be anticipating. It’s as if Ms. Saunders is trying to go around the school districts’ superintendents, thinking that if they are in place for a year, or less, they will be less aligned with the school boards than they would be otherwise. Perhaps she thinks that lack of competency or experience makes her job easier. That’s misguided, to say the least.

This isn’t an argument against the consolidation of our school districts. We have too many, and they are costly and inefficient. The way we structure our schools no longer works, particularly in our more rural environments. Our declining test results are proof positive. But trying to apply such a radical change statewide, or as opportunity allows, ignores not only Vermont’s record on systemic change - which is virtually nothing - but also threatens to weaken the state’s educational system even more.

Schools are among the most complicated institutions we have. They all have multi-million-dollar budgets. They have unions to contend with. They have a public that must be tended to. They have school boards that need to be aligned with their schools’ aspirations. And they have histories that, if not understood, can derail the most honorable plans. That’s not an easy transition for someone new to the job, the area, or the politics.

It’s ridiculous. 

Consider Vermont’s march toward educational reform. Any reform. Ever. Does anything jump out that was accomplished in a single year? No. It takes time. So if Ms. Saunders prevails and gets school districts to hire superintendents for 12-month stints, all she has done is make a difficult process even more difficult, and far messier.  She will also have made her relationships with Vermont’s school districts less tenable than they already are.

Understandably, Ms. Saunders wants to speed things up. If Mr. Scott wins another term, it will almost certainly be his last, which means Ms. Saunders is also on her last stint. But putting school districts under the command of superintendents whose contracts end before they really know what’s happening is a fool’s errand and will only slow the process. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here