One bright idea deserves another

Posted

When the solar power industry in Vermont got its start it was recognized that it would not succeed if it were not subsidized and that subsidy, provided by utility ratepayers, would need to be in place until the industry had sufficient strength to stand on its own. Two decades later, we are there.

The Department of Public Service, the state entity that represents the public’s interest when it comes to the cost of energy, is advocating that the way we pay solar power producers be changed to reflect the industry’s self-sufficiency. The system at the center of things – net metering – should be cut so that ratepayers are no longer subsidizing an industry that doesn’t need the help. The department is recommending the subsidy be cut in half, which, obviously, would help individual homeowners and businesses.

By anyone’s standards, the net metering program has been successful in Vermont. We rank 25th nationally in the total amount of solar-installations, which is astounding given our small population and the little amount of land we have in comparison to others. Today we generate over 300 megawatts of solar power, which, on a per capita basis, is near the nation’s top.

The net metering system was put in place in 1998 and it works by allowing homeowners and businesses to build renewable energy systems and then use the electricity generated to offset what they use with the energy they produce. If they produce more than they use, they get to sell the power back to the utility at a price comfortably above the market rate.

It was an incentivized system that was a win-win. The energy produced was renewable and the industry created was robust – close to an estimated 6,000 jobs. By any standards, it’s now a mature industry. It no longer needs the extra money the ratepayers have been providing.

Even industry leaders, like Sun Common, agree the subsidies need to be drawn down to be more appropriate.

It’s no small amount of money. Green Mountain Power, the utility responsible for serving three-fourths of Vermont, estimates the cost-shift to be in the neighborhood of $33 million annually. That’s $33 million that could be used to reduce future rate increases, or it’s $33 million that could be used to meet its goal of addressing climate change through other electrification projects. When the cost of power is lowered then almost by definition the renewable energy choices broaden.

That’s important because at this point the extra dollars going to subsidize solar produce marginal value in terms of addressing climate change. Only 10 percent of the state’s greenhouse emissions come from electricity, as compared to the national average of 28 percent. Almost three-quarters of our emissions are produced from the cars we drive and the way we heat our homes and businesses. If the cost of electricity can be pushed down, then figuring out ways to deal with transportation and heating become more achievable. These are the sorts of opportunities that can make a difference on the climate change front.

Here’s one example: the average cost for a high level EV charging station is a bit less than $2,000. If the $33 million GMP’s rate payers are shelling out for solar were devoted to those charging stations, that would be 16,500 charging stations. Each year. In a decade that would be 165,000. You get the idea.

The Department of Public Service has made it clear it has no interest in changing the system so rapidly and so drastically that it puts at risk what is in place. What the department is saying is that it was made clear from the outset that it was unfair to ratepayers to subsidize businesses that are sustainable on their own. That’s the position of the solar power industry, in the main. While there will be those businesses that have built the subsidies into their expected earnings, it’s not the responsibility of the state and its ratepayers to continue the practice. In fact, as the challenge of climate change looms larger and larger, it’s more important than ever for the ratepayers to have their money focused where it produces the greatest value.

This is the perspective that should be put in play as the department starts to figure out how to scale down the net metering program. In sum, the program worked wonders. A viable industry was built and it’s sustainable. As the evidence of climate change becomes more certain, it’s time we use available resources to leverage new potentials, and those resources can be employed by lowering ratepayer costs, or by using the same money for different, more valuable pursuits.

It’s a good news story almost any way you look at it.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here