No one leaves until the gov says so. Good.

Posted

Gov. Phil Scott has made it clear he will not allow the Legislature to adjourn without agreeing on legislation that reforms the state’s educational system. If it takes the remainder of the year, he says so be it. 

Legislators left Montpelier last Friday with instructions from the leadership that a vote would be set for June 16, assuming the conferees have settled their differences. But the conferees -three from the House and three from the Senate - are miles apart. It’s anyone’s guess what may evolve or whether legislators are willing to play a game of chicken with the governor.

That uncertainty hangs over the heads of Democratic legislators caught betwixt and between. They lost their supermajority last November by ignoring the political firestorm caused by the 14 percent hike in people’s property taxes. Dismiss the need for reform and Democrats could easily face another round of political losses. Then again, there are parts of the reform packages that have political downsides, things like minimum class sizes, consolidation of school districts, and a foundation formula that has yet to be fully vetted, let alone agreed upon. For some, it looks like a lose-lose proposition.

Adding to that uncertainty is the political calculus involving Mr. Scott. He’s a five-term governor whose popularity is off-the-charts high. It makes a great deal of difference to Democrats whether the governor steps down, or opts for another term. If they are convinced he won’t run for a sixth term, there is less pressure on them to push for an aggressive reform package, one that cuts deeper and is implemented sooner than they would like.

But given his temperament, his bipartisan support, and the fact that he would be Vermont’s longest-serving governor, we’d think the surest way for Democrats to push him into running for another term would be to say no to his crusade to reform Vermont’s educational system or to limit it to any significant degree.

For the Democrats, there is no easy way out. Conferees will need to find ways to compromise, to make it appear they are at least meeting the governor’s insistence that costs will be reduced.

The deeper the argument goes, the narrower the plank Democrats walk. When the NEAP scores came out earlier this year, they painted a bleak picture of Vermont’s educational outcomes. It used to be that Vermont ranked in the top 10 states when it came to its quality of education. No longer. 

Here’s one recent snap-shot: According to an analysis by Watershed-advisors, an educational assessment think-tank, Vermont ranked 47th nationally when it looked at the percentage change for fourth graders who were “at or above proficient” in reading from the years 2013 to 2024. We are 37th when our fourth graders were tested for math, 21st when our eighth graders were tested on math, 23rd for our fourth graders on reading, and 21st for our 8th graders on their reading.

Not great. 

Not for a state with the lowest number of kids per class. 

Not for a state with more teachers per student than any other state. 

Not for a state that spends roughly $27,000 per student, which is about $10,000 more per student than the national average.

Not for a state whose per-pupil spending has soared more than 60 percent while its student population has declined a full 20 percent since the turn of the century. That’s an unholy alliance if there ever was one.

So, as the conferees try to find a path through their briar patch of differences there are other challenges that must loom large in their minds. Not only do they need to reach a consensus that puts downward pressure on school costs they must also do so in a way that addresses academic outcomes and “little things” like the $6 billion tab identified for deferred maintenance.

This session’s focus on the need to reform our educational system is long overdue. And it’s a difficult one for a state that has 241 towns, roughly 300 schools, a long history of local control, and a hide-bound reluctance to change.

But we’re here. Lock the doors. There’s a lot of work to do.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here