NMC and its survival case before the GMCB

Posted

Northwestern Medical Center’s distinction among the state’s 14 hospitals is that it has consistently been the state’s lowest-cost health care provider. This was true 30-odd years ago, and it’s reasonably close today. 

For years, NMC has presented its spartan budgets as “the right thing to do.” And they were. From a day’s cash-on-hand perspective, the St. Albans-based hospital was one of the state’s strongest.  When the Green Mountain Care Board was established in 2011, NMC’s “excess of cash” was even identified as a sign the hospital could cut back without putting its operations at risk.

That was then. Over the last nine years, NMC has lost an average of $4 million. The only year the hospital didn’t lose money was during COVID, when the federal government came to its rescue.

The decline continues. Today, NMC goes before the GMCB with a budget approved by its board that anticipates a $4.5 million loss. But it’s a budget that is at odds with what the GMCB wants. The GMCB recognizes NMC is the state’s low-cost hospital. Accordingly, the board’s directives for NMC are less onerous than the directives for other hospitals. NMC is being allowed a higher net patient revenue figure of 1 percent, an increase of its operating expenses of 2.4 percent, and an increase in commercial rates of one percent. 

In comparison, the state’s regulator has directed other hospitals to cut their net patient revenue by one percent or more, to cut their commercial rate increases by one percent or more, and limit their operating expenses to 2.4 percent or less.

Obviously, the board is giving NMC a break. But if NMC were forced to abide by the board’s proposal, NMC’s deficit would jump from $4.5 million to about $10 million.

That’s a problem. NMC has 175 days of cash on hand. Even if the GMCB accepted the hospital’s budget, the $4.5 million loss would result in the hospital losing 11 days of cash. If NMC followed the GMCB’s guidance, the hospital would have a $10 million budget deficit, which would mean the hospital’s reserves would drop by over 20 days. In today’s testimony, NMC CEO Jonathan Billings says NMC would be out of money in four years. NMC has already violated one of its bond covenants related to its declining reserves. They will violate others as their cash dwindles. 

That’s not a comforting picture. Not for NMC. Nor for its employees. Not for its patients. And not for the community. 

The hospital is hyper-aware of its circumstances. Thus, in the name of survival, it’s asking the board for leniency. For starters, it’s asking for a 6.67 percent increase in outpatient and inpatient services for FY27. 

If the GMCB were to accept, NMC would still be one of the state’s least expensive [10th lowest out of 14 hospitals]. NMC is also proposing a move to reference-based pricing, which would peg its rates to those paid by Medicare, commonly the lowest-cost health care payer. This would limit what private insurance plans pay hospitals for care. It’s a direct way to lower health care costs for Vermonters. NMC would also be the first hospital in the state to shift to reference-based pricing, no small consideration.

NMC’s plight - which is being mirrored across the state - is a key reason we have made the argument that the GMCB needs to have its authority expanded. It makes no sense for the board to have the authority to control hospitals’ budget but not have the authority, or responsibility, to guide the hospitals to a more stable and productive place. Hospitals cannot do this by themselves. Nor can the governor’s office, or the Legislature, or the community.

It doesn’t make sense to have the GMCB create budget issues for hospitals without telling them how to manage their businesses so they can keep the doors open and provide quality health care.

This need is immediate, as NMC makes clear. The hospital has been the lowest-priced hospital in Vermont for decades. It’s also been one of the strongest hospitals financially. If NMC is staring at a four-year timeline before running out of cash, what does the rest of the state’s healthcare community look like?

We would encourage the GMCB to accept NMC’s proposed budget, but we would also encourage the powers that be to point the way forward for the state’s hospitals. It’s a given our hospitals need to change, but, as in NMC’s case, that can’t be done from a position of rapid decline.

The GMCB needs the authority and the resources to restore what’s clearly at risk.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here