Ms. Sheldon brings common sense to debate

Posted

Thank you, Rep. Amy Sheldon, D-Middlebury.

It was Ms. Sheldon, chair of the House Environmental Committee, who on Tuesday did an about-face and said she would work to repeal portions of Act 181 that much of rural Vermont felt had robbed them of their personal property rights and hurt the state’s ability to build more housing.

Ms. Sheldon said, “We don’t need our shared interest in protecting our environment to divide Vermont, particularly at this moment.”

Ms. Sheldon has a deserved reputation as a conservationist, and she was one of the key defenders of Act 181 when it was passed two years ago.  By saying she would move her committee to repeal both the “road rule” and “tier 3” development restrictions, she single-handedly changed the conversation about the law and its impact.

Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth said he was “shocked” by Ms. Sheldon’s change of mind. Sen. Anne Watson, D/P-Washington, said she would be “unlikely to resist” the House’s changes.

When the law was passed in 2024, it was designed to recast Act 250, the state’s half-century-old development review policy law. It sought to make development in already developed areas easier and put in place a process whereby the state would be mapped to control where new growth would happen and where it wouldn’t.

As the details of the law became public, it became clear that those who lived in rural areas faced a more restrictive environment, perhaps even losing the right to decide how, or if, their property could be developed. The “road rule”, for example, meant that roads longer than 800 feet in Tier 2 areas would require a state permit. Restrictions were even stricter for Tier 3 areas, which include the state’s more sensitive ecosystems.

The legislation was pitched as a law to help address the state’s housing needs by relaxing Act 250 regulations in areas already developed, paying much less attention to what would happen elsewhere. As we noted at the time, the new law dramatically expanded the reach of Act 250, and it created a rural/urban divide.

Typically, that sort of divide in Vermont is ignored.  The votes are in the city, not the hinterland, and Vermont’s environmental organizations [key supporters of Act 181] are among the strongest lobbying forces in the state.

But rural Vermont rose up and found its voice. Even housing groups like Let’s Grow Homes understood how the new law could jeopardize the state’s ability to meet its housing needs. Equally, if not more important, those who testified against the bill, those who protested outside the state’s Capitol, and those who wrote letters in opposition brought awareness to the fact that the last thing Vermont needs is a law that shuts down rural Vermont’s ability to prosper. 

It was probably a mistake for the Legislature to use Act 250 as the vehicle to guide development and to protect the state’s more sensitive ecosystems. We have other laws that would suffice. If, as assumed, the Legislature does repeal the “road rule” and the “tier 3” portions of the law, it’s essential that the lessons learned from this experience are remembered and applied. 

It doesn’t work to pass laws that strip people of their rights. It doesn’t work to pass laws only to have the impact of the law understood much later. And it doesn’t work to pass a law that essentially scrubs rural Vermont of its future.  It’s hard to make something better if there’s nobody there. 

Obvious as that might be, it takes a lot of courage for someone to stand up and say they have listened to people’s concerns and found themselves in error. That there is a better way, that it’s crucial in our divided land to find consensus. 

Ms. Sheldon did that. That’s not a small thing. 

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here