On June 21, 1989, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of Gregory Lee Johnson, a protestor who chose to burn the American flag outside the Republican convention in Dallas. The court ruled it was protected expression under the First Amendment, at the time an unpopular ruling with most Americans. There are similar cases involving the importance of free speech, examples of how by securing the rights of individuals like Mr. Johnson the courts protect the constitutional rights of the rest of us.
That protection we take as inviolate is being challenged by the Trump administration. Shockingly, right here in our backyard.
Today Mohsen Mahdawi, with ties to the Upper Valley, sits in the Northwest State Correctional Facility in St. Albans Town. He was arrested by immigration officials on Monday in Colchester, assumably pending deportation. No pertinent information has been offered. Yet, he is a lawful permanent resident of the United States. He has a green card. He’s lived here for a full decade. He’s following the path to being a naturalized citizen.
His incarceration should frighten us. It could be you. It could be any of us. The Trump administration is operating as if the decision is theirs.
Mr. Mahdawi was born and raised in a refugee camp in the West Bank. He moved to the United States in 2014 and attended Columbia University. He was a critic of Israel’s military campaign in Gaza and was involved in organizing student protests at Columbia. He was never an advocate of violence, and, in fact, was caught on camera saying “…we are against antisemitism because antisemitism is a form of injustice, and injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” He’s a practicing Buddhist.
Yet, he was arrested and lodged in the St. Albans prison because he was advocating on behalf of Palestinians. He was arrested Monday, almost a year after the demonstrations at Columbia, under the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952, which the Trump administration is using to arrest and deport anyone believed to be a “threat to the country.” Secretary of State Marco Rubio claims the right for the administration to deport anyone based on their beliefs or speech.
Standing in front of Columbia University students and advocating for peace in Gaza could have, as Mr. Rubio says, “serious adverse foreign policy consequences?”
Talk about a low bar. In other words, the president could have immigration officials arrest almost anyone who expresses their disagreement with him.
[Interestingly, since Mr. Mandawi’s arrest it’s been Jewish groups who have come to his defense, calling his arrest a “cynical form of antisemitism.”]
President Trump has made it clear he will not tolerate opposition, even targeting lawyers who handle immigration cases that challenge his authority or direction. His threat to withhold billions of dollars in federal grants to universities to achieve “viewpoint diversity” [as long as it’s his point of view] is in direct opposition to the Constitution’s protections as clearly stated by numerous Supreme Court rulings. Yet, he pushes forward, contending the law doesn’t apply to him.
It’s the same arrogance, and willful disregard for the rule of law that has Kilma Abrego Garcia sitting in a prison in El Salvador even though the administration acknowledges he was mistakenly arrested and flown to El Salvador without any regard to due process.
Is that to be Mr, Mahdawi’s fate?
The only good news is that Vermont’s U.S. District Court Judge William Sessions III quickly issued a temporary restraining order to prohibit Mr. Mahdawi’s removal from Vermont or the U.S. without further orders by the court.
Our congressional delegation is also aware of Mr. Mahdawi’s case and is livid. Gov. Phil Scott, of the president’s own political party, parted ways with the president with a sharp rebuke on Tuesday.
“Yesterday, Vermonters witnessed the arrest of Mohsen Mandawi, a foreign national with legal status to be in the United States of America. That legal status, the Bill of Rights, and Constitution of the United States, all grant him, and all people, fundamental rights - including due process,” the governor said. Mr. Scott essentially called those who arrested him cowards. “What cannot be justified, is how this action was undertaken. Law enforcement officers in this country should not operate in the shadows or hide behind masks.”
We should all take offense at the arrest and detention of Mr. Mahdawi, and we should all be frightened of this administration’s abuse of the Constitution and its rule of law. That could be us.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here