The Vermont House last week passed its education reform bill, inviting a less-than-enthusiastic response from Gov. Phil Scott and the promise from the Senate that it would go a different way.
The governor said the bill had little to recommend, except it satisfied the procedural need to move the legislation from the House to the Senate. He said the bill’s timeline was too long and it falls short of the money it would save, among other things. The Senate has already begun its work on the legislation, but differs on the reduced number of school districts Vermont should have, how tuition should work with independent schools, and the need to preserve school choice as it exists. Unlike the House and Governor, the Senate, so far, does not recommend average class size minimums. All three parties seem, however, to agree on switching to a foundation formula for financing our schools.
The House version also opposes the governor’s move to shift rule-making responsibilities from the State Board of Education to the secretary of the Agency of Education. The House bill strengthens the board and the Legislature would be able to enlarge the board with two members of its own choice. The House also addresses the need to recognize school construction needs, which has not been done since 2008.
What the final bill will look like is anyone’s guess. The goal, however, is no mystery. Vermont needs an educational system that costs less and does a better job for our students. It needs a system that puts a priority on efficiency; what works and what doesn’t.
On this point, the House got it right. So did the governor. The Senate has not. Vermont’s needs cannot be met without reducing the number of its schools. Period. Both the governor and the House have recognized this by setting minimum class sizes. The House’s recommendations would allow for classes to be smaller than what the governor’s proposal recommends. The House bill also allows schools to apply for a waiver from the State Board of Education if they can’t meet the proposed class size minimums. The Senate - thus far - is staying away from the issue.
It’s axiomatic we cannot lose 30,000 students and maintain the same number of schools and staffing. But that’s essentially what we're doing. And it’s easy to understand why groups like the Rural School Community Alliance are mounting a fierce battle against any legislation that includes minimum class size goals.
In a release last week, the group said: “…the [House] bill ignores the consequences for rural communities in Vermont, a state that is predominantly rural. School closures lead to population decline, reduced property values, loss of social capital, and difficulties attracting and retaining families…”
The group opposes virtually everything the Legislature and the governor are proposing. They have sizable numbers behind them. Most of Vermont is rural. The Legislature is filled with those who represent them.
Regardless, what the group does not consider is how costs will be lowered. The group's only suggestion is “payment reform,” which is not an answer. If the Legislature ends up with a bill that does not address class size minimums and does not reduce the number of school districts, then we will have a bill that does very little to reduce costs or improve educational outcomes. We can’t “payment reform” our way out of the costly ditch we’re in.
Legislators [and the governor] should also consider the cost involved in school construction needs, which have been estimated to cost $6 billion over the next decade. Does it make sense to put construction money into a school that struggles to have more than a handful of students in its classrooms?
It does not. If a school struggles to have more than a handful of children in the classroom and is identified as in dire need of repair should that not be additional evidence the school may need closing?
We have been putting off true educational reform for the last quarter century. We’ve not adjusted to what we have known was coming our way. The procrastination - or outright denial - has cost us severely.
The House bill is a minimum, and its step forward on class size requirements should be recognized for the courage it represents. That's no small achievement politically. Let’s hope that when the final gavel falls on this session the legislation is even stronger.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here