Local educators need to lead the discussion

Posted

As the School District Redistricting Task Force begins its effort to consolidate Vermont’s 52 supervisory unions and 119 school districts into something more manageable and less expensive, there is, as expected, a full-throated chorus in opposition. There is also the politically astute positioning themselves in ways to protect their interests. Neither is unexpected. 

When Gov. Phil Scott signed H.454 into law, he put in play a plan to turn Vermont’s educational system upside down, beginning with the move to redraw new school district boundaries. The task force will present the Legislature no more than three options by December. The operative guideline is that each option should have districts with 4,000 to 8,000 pre-K through grade 12 students. [Presently, the Champlain Valley School District is the only district in the state to have more than 4,000 students.]

Should the process proceed as directed the districts would be formalized in 2028, the same year the new funding formula would also take effect. The 11-member task force was also told to make its choices in a way that created the least disruption.

Good luck with that.

But the process needn’t be as confrontational as we might expect. 

Under the governor’s direction, there would be 12 school districts. He would combine Essex and Caledonia counties, split Grand Isle between Franklin and Chittenden County, and have the remaining counties with a single district.

That’s a massive consolidation. Likely more than Vermonters could stomach. Take Franklin County, for example. Is it operationally and educationally the best idea to combine all our schools into one district? From Richford to Georgia?

Probably not. 

But the county could be split into two districts, which would still be a massive consolidation. It would also be better academically. When you talk to local educators the optimum size for a school district is roughly 4,000 students. While the task force may be expected to give the governor what he wants - 12 districts - it’s vital that the task force also have one of its plans on the bigger end of the spectrum. [20 is a lot less than 119, which should temper any suggestion that the task force didn’t do its job.]

It would also be naive to believe the task force will speed through its job with no pushback. The  Vermont NEA is already putting together a campaign to get more teachers interested in the political process. The union fully understands the importance of having more legislators in Montpelier who are advocates for their profession. There are also various groups that have already made it known they will oppose any consolidation efforts that threaten the viability of their schools through such things as mandatory class sizes.

So how does the task force invite the public to be part of the process without surrendering to those whose intent is limited to their self-interest?

One way would be to invite the supervisory unions in each county to first propose their own plans. For example, the superintendents in Franklin County could put together their defense for a two-district proposal. And it would do so sooner rather than later. There is power in leading the discussion. It’s being proactive, not reactive. It shows the task force - and the public - that they have reviewed the alternatives and that they can defend their choice. 

To do that would require our supervisory unions to put in the work to show the task force and the voters that they have considered all options. It’s work that should be made public and defended accordingly.

Think about it. Is it not a smarter choice to first hear from those whose everyday jobs it is to figure out what’s best for our students?

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here