It’s good to know that perhaps there is a limit to the chaos President Trump is willing to suffer. His 90-day pause on his ill-conceived “reciprocal” tariffs gave the markets reason to think the darkest of scenarios would be avoided. On Wednesday the indexes soared to historic levels, following his announcement. On Thursday, however, the markets gave back half the prior day’s gain. We’re still in an extraordinary trade war with China, the world’s second-largest economy, and have yet to absorb the global scale of what the president has done in declaring the largest tariff shock in history. There is no guarantee the president will not reimpose the tariffs. There is no guarantee of anything, except that Mr. Trump will do what he wants, when he wants, and to whom he wants, absent any coherent strategy, guided only by his whims.
All this and he’s got 1,380 days, or 95 percent of his second term as president remaining. How’s that for a dark thought?
It’s particularly concerning for Vermonters. Our largest trading partner is Canada, specifically the Quebec province. We import over $2.6 billion in goods and the imposed tariffs have changed the topography for Vermont’s businesses. There is little certainty as to the cost of goods, and our small-business economy is already struggling, having to contemplate a path forward.
But it’s more than an issue of the moment. The worry is that part of the damage done is the trust that has been lost. In a Vermont Public story, a Canadian Federation for Independent Businesses survey showed that nearly half its 100,000 members “no longer have faith in the United States as a reliable trading partner.”
It was also acknowledged by Tim Tierney, director of international trade at the Vermont Agency of Commerce and Development, that the president’s inflammatory rhetoric is what matters most to Canadians. “Sometimes it’s the rhetoric that has the deepest wounds here. And that might be harder to heal than just a trade war,” he said.
That must have been on the minds of Senate President Phil Baruth and House Speaker Jill Krowinski as they took the unusual step of testifying before legislative committees who are trying to calculate the impact of Mr. Trump’s tariffs on Vermont’s economy.
Both leaders essentially offered an apology to Canada and Canadians. “…Our business relationships with Canada … are the mainstay of our economy here in Vermont … And we will not let it go unremarked that the president has wounded us economically,” Mr. Baruth said.
For a state that is already struggling with its own affordability issues, and a state that has stressed the need for growth, this is an unanticipated challenge that could make the state’s economic future problematic. If the newly imposed tariffs last the duration of this administration, how do we respond?
The challenge goes beyond tariffs. The president this week took direct aim at Vermont and it’s first-in-the-nation climate superfund law by directing the U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi to find ways to stop the law’s enforcement, which he said threatens “American energy dominance.”
The worry is that if the fight broadens the administration may extend its tariffs to include Green Mountain Power’s import of energy from Hydro-Quebec. That tariff would be a direct cost the utility would have to pass on to the consumer.
That would be another big hit to the state’s economy and to the affordability issues facing Vermonters.
Again, what’s to be done?
The hope is that Congress will rethink its wisdom in granting a single person -the president - the power to do so much damage. Simply stated: Congress needs to reclaim its ability to strip the president’s tariff powers. It’s better that power is in the hands of 535 voting members of Congress than a single person in the White House.
That’s at least one answer to the chaos.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here