Two problems require substantial changes in policy and approach if Vermont is to control its costs and the quality of its services. The first is education, the second is health care. Both cost too much, and both are beginning to lose the quality of services offered.
Gov. Phil Scott is said to be on the verge of delivering an in-depth proposal to deal with our schools and the Legislature has noted its willingness to work with him. There is good reason to expect a productive outcome; Democrats want to make the issue part of their past. Taxpayers have made the issue their primary concern and intend to apply the pressure until they see relief.
Then, there’s health care, which not only applies to school budgets but to the everyday life of all Vermonters. Not only are healthcare premiums unreasonably high [we have the highest rates nationally], we have a healthcare system that, according to a consultant’s report, is on the verge of collapse.
Heretofore, it’s been a problem that the governor and Legislature have opted not to address. It’s highly complicated and deals with an industry that represents 20 percent of the state’s economy. It’s also an issue without an easy answer. In other words, politically there is more downside to getting involved than upside.
That reluctance to lead took a turn for the better last week when the governor signed an agreement with the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] to move the state toward a new healthcare reform model called AHEAD.
The model would allow GMCB to put participating hospitals under a global budget and would provide the state’s primary care doctors regular payments. The underlying purpose is not unlike the one long provided by OneCare Vermont, which was to pitch a payment reform plan that would steer hospitals away from fee-for-service to payments that stressed the need for preventative care.
OneCare Vt will close its doors at year’s end, for a variety of reasons. But king among them was its lack of authority and a backroom hesitancy by providers who saw themselves vulnerable to the process.
If the AHEAD program were to succeed in Vermont it would have the decision making authority over roughly $3 billion in federal Medicaid and Medicare money spent in Vermont. The powers involved would be the state, under the Agency of Human Services, and the Green Mountain Care Board, the state’s healthcare regulator.
The GMCB voted 3-1 in favor of the move, with one of its members abstaining. Board Chair Owen Foster, was quoted as saying it was the most difficult decision the board has yet to make. “If the model is not adequately regulated and sufficiently resourced, it will fail dramatically and harm patients and harm our health system.”
To protect themselves and the state’s healthcare system the board built in six conditions that had to be met before the board would fully commit to the process. Included in the conditions was the need for the feds to buy into the process, as outlined by the state, and for the governor and Legislature to provide the additional staffing necessary to monitor and guide the state’s healthcare system and its providers. Mr. Owen said the board would need 20 qualified staffers to handle the task.
The proposal would not start until 2027 and would last for nine years. But, as with all such projects, there is concern about the state’s involvement in deciding what a hospital should spend. Administrations come and go, raising questions of consistency. There is the accompanying concern about restrictive budgets being an excuse for hospitals to ration their care, which is already an issue.
That said, what we suffer from most of all is a lack of credible information about our healthcare system and what can be done to make it more affordable and to protect the quality of its services. Which is why the GMCB is asking for a substantial increase in its staffing. The board doesn’t have the manpower to figure out what works and what doesn’t. The Legislature and the administration suffer from the same lack of in-depth research.
Not only does this knowledge not exist with the GMCB or the Legislature, it would take a substantial amount of time and resources to put this staffing in place, which is why the effort would need to begin now, with the upcoming governor’s budget.
Nothing has changed from when the board’s out-of-state consultant Oliver Wyman delivered its bleak assessment of the state’s healthcare community several months ago. Costs are still rising. Our hospitals are running on fumes, with low to non-existent margins. Guidance is minimal to non-existent. The public doesn’t know how to respond other than to be defensive of what it has.
Like it or not, Vermont’s healthcare environment is one that is highly regulated in comparison to most states. To get this right, which includes bringing down enough federal dollars to make it work, means also drawing the talent here to provide the necessary information upon which to make the right decisions. It sounds so minimal. It’s anything but.
What we can’t do is what we’ve done with education, which is to kick the can down the road for decades until we didn’t have a choice. That’s now where we are with healthcare. We don’t have a choice.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here