Being the town clerk in Vermont is not what it used to be, according to a Vermont Public story. The spillover from the nastiness of social media is making its way into our town halls. Our open meetings, the hallmark of our democracy, are marked by the toxic nature of how we communicate.
Why is this happening?
Part of the explanation is the anonymity that social media offers. People don’t have to identify themselves, so they can say what they would like without anyone knowing. Part of the explanation is how tech companies set up their algorithms, which naturally spin conversations to the extreme. And part of the explanation is that this toxicity is being blessed by our political leaders, all the way up to the presidency.
If the president can be nasty and vengeful and suffer no consequences, can’t the rest of us do the same?
Apparently, some of us think so. As the Vermont Public story noted, the town of Strafford had to lock its front door and only allow people in by appointment after a local citizen threatened the town clerk and its selectboard. In nearby Alburgh, selectboard meetings were disrupted by a man unhappy about how the selectboard was dealing with an issue involving the local sheriff.
It’s that sense of potential violence that threatens the stability of our democracy. People stop running for office; they don’t want the hassle or the fear. The public is less inclined to attend a public meeting.
It’s important enough that the Legislature passed a law last session that gives selectboards instructions as to when they can remove someone from a public meeting and what defines “disorderly conduct.” The bill was introduced by Sen. Ruth Hardy, D-Middlebury, who acknowledged the difficulty of defining when free speech lapses over into language that threatens.
“I think we need to, as a society, be able to have pubic buildings that are open to the public, and we also have to keep our pubic officials safe. So, trying to figure out a balance of access to the public and safety of public officials is really hard,” she said.
As we are reminded by the ACLU, it’s crucial to balance the rights of individuals to exercise their constitutional rights with the rights of the public [and government employees] to be provided a safe environment. That safe environment could include installing windows between the employee and the public. It could include all areas being recorded. It could include sentence minimums for people who need to be escorted out of any public meeting.
But the overall objective is two-fold; first, to create a safe environment for public servants, and, second, to do a better job spreading the message to the public at large - when a leader acts with vengeance or cruelty, it legitimizes similar behavior among the citizenry. It signals that empathy is weakness and hostility is strength. That’s wrong, and we should act against it.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here